| Day 1 |
| Milwaukee Cavaliers76-86 D. McLain, R (17-9, 3.18 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox79-83 T. Seaver, R (17-14, 4.51 ERA) |
| Kansas City Monarchs100-68 J. Verlander, R (17-9, 3.99 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals90-78 J. Marichal, R (17-14, 3.25 ERA) |
| St. Louis Browns107-65 C. Sweeney, R (16-10, 4.26 ERA) | | | Chicago White Sox88-75 R. Guidry, L (14-13, 4.11 ERA) |
| Atlanta Braves68-94 D. Leonard, L (9-19, 3.94 ERA) | | | Toledo Mud Hens91-77 R. Clemens, R (16-12, 3.53 ERA) |
| Detroit Stars97-83 E. Morris, L (12-13, 4.99 ERA) | | | Philadelphia A's72-90 J. deGrom, R (14-14, 3.45 ERA) |
| Baltimore Elites69-93 B. Donovan, R (12-12, 4.55 ERA) | | | Indianapolis ABC's57-105 W. White, R (3-3, 4.99 ERA) |
| Homestead Grays95-72 V. Blue, L (18-11, 3.59 ERA) | | | Cleveland Indians105-75 C. Griffith, R (17-11, 5.00 ERA) |
| Louisville Black Caps76-86 C. Ferguson, R (9-16, 4.29 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds75-87 L. Tiant, R (12-16, 3.71 ERA) |
| Omaha Royals80-82 D. Vance, R (6-11, 5.58 ERA) | | | Brooklyn Dodgers63-99 M. Scott, R (11-18, 4.29 ERA) |
| New York Giants99-75 C. Mathewson, R (16-9, 3.53 ERA) | | | New York Yankees74-88 G. Cole, R (16-12, 4.12 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Milwaukee Cavaliers76-86 H. Brecheen, L (8-18, 5.14 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox79-83 P. Alexander, R (18-11, 3.17 ERA) |
| Kansas City Monarchs100-68 S. Koufax, L (18-10, 3.65 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals90-78 C. Rodon, L (15-12, 3.76 ERA) |
| St. Louis Browns107-65 W. Spahn, L (16-10, 3.79 ERA) | | | Chicago White Sox88-75 K. Appier, R (16-11, 3.38 ERA) |
| Atlanta Braves68-94 D. Luque, R (10-19, 4.41 ERA) | | | Toledo Mud Hens91-77 E. Walsh, R (13-14, 4.80 ERA) |
| Detroit Stars97-83 H. Nomo, R (17-14, 3.70 ERA) | | | Philadelphia A's72-90 R. Waddell, L (11-13, 4.38 ERA) |
| Baltimore Elites69-93 P. Galvin, R (6-18, 6.62 ERA) | | | Indianapolis ABC's57-105 P. Hentgen, R (0-3, 6.69 ERA) |
| Homestead Grays95-72 R. Ford, R (19-11, 3.25 ERA) | | | Cleveland Indians105-75 W. Johnson, R (23-9, 3.66 ERA) |
| Louisville Black Caps76-86 B. Veale, L (13-15, 4.14 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds75-87 R. Ray, L (12-10, 4.09 ERA) |
| Omaha Royals80-82 C. Hamels, L (10-14, 5.46 ERA) | | | Brooklyn Dodgers63-99 J. Ward, R (8-25, 5.60 ERA) |
| New York Giants99-75 J. Santana, L (15-12, 3.64 ERA) | | | New York Yankees74-88 E. Seward, R (10-19, 4.98 ERA) |