| Player (Team) | Tagged |
|---|
| Adams, Babe (Pirates) | Franchise Player |
| Arrieta, Jake (Twins) | Franchise Player |
| Baker, Angel (Reds) | Rookie/Prospect |
| Becker, Charlie (Twin Saints) | free agent holders |
| Benoit, Joaquin (Rays) | Franchise Player |
| Blalock, Hank (Twins) | free agent holders |
| Blue, Vida (Athletics) | Franchise Player |
| Boggs, Wade (Rays) | Franchise Player |
| Bonds, Barry (Giants) | Franchise Player |
| Bonds, Barry (Pirates) | Franchise Player |
| Bosman, Dick (Rangers) | Franchise Player |
| Braun, Ryan (Brew Sounds) | Franchise Player |
| Burrell, Pat (loafers) | free agent holders |
| Carter, Wyatt (Cardinals) | Rookie/Prospect |
| Carter, Gary (M-Rainers) | free agent holders |
| Cash, Norm (Tigers) | Franchise Player |
| Cavarretta, Phil (Cubs) | Franchise Player |
| Cepeda, Orlando (Orange Mets) | free agent holders |
| Clarke, Fred (Pirates) | Franchise Player |
| Clemens, Roger (Yankees) | Franchise Player |
| Cole, Gerrit (Twins) | Franchise Player |
| Collins, Eddie (Athletics) | Franchise Player |
| deGrom, Jacob (Rangers) | Franchise Player |
| Diaz, Edwin (Mariners) | Franchise Player |
| Dugan, Brandon (Giants) | Rookie/Prospect |
| Dull, Ryan (Brewers) | choice rookie |
| Dumont, George (Twins) | free agent holders |
| Eckersley, Dennis (Athletics) | Franchise Player |
| Eldred, Cal (Brew Sounds) | Franchise Player |
| English, Woody (Cubs) | Franchise Player |
| Flaherty, Jack (Cardinals) | Franchise Player |
| Foxx, Jimmie (Mariners) | Franchise Player |
| Garver, Mitch (Twin Saints) | Franchise Player |
| Gehrig, Lou (Yankees) | Franchise Player |
| Giambi, Jason (Athletics) | Franchise Player |
| Gibson, Bob (Cardinals) | Franchise Player |
| Glasnow, Tyler (Rays) | Franchise Player |
| Gomez, Carlos (Brew Sounds) | Franchise Player |
| Gordon, Joe (Yankees) | free agent holders |
| Greinke, Zack (Dodgers) | Franchise Player |
| Griffey, Ken (Mariners) | Franchise Player |
| Hamels, Cole (Mariners) | Franchise Player |
| Hamilton, Josh (Mets) | Franchise Player |
| Hansen, Ron (White Sox) | Franchise Player |
| Hauser, Adam (Athletics) | Rookie/Prospect |
| Henderson, Rickey (Athletics) | Franchise Player |
| Hernandez, Felix (Mariners) | Franchise Player |
| Hernandez, Keith (Mets) | Franchise Player |
| Hill, Rich (Cubs) | Franchise Player |
| Hornsby, Rogers (Cardinals) | Franchise Player |
| Hoskins, Rhys (loafers) | free agent holders |
| Hunter, Catfish (A'viators) | Franchise Player |
| Jackson, Joe (White Sox) | Franchise Player |
| Jansen, Kenley (Dodgers) | Franchise Player |
| Johnson, Randy (Mariners) | Franchise Player |
| Johnson, Walter (Twins) | Franchise Player |
| Kelly, King (Cubs) | Franchise Player |
| Kenders, Peter (Rangers) | Rookie/Prospect |
| Kershaw, Clayton (Dodgers) | Franchise Player |
| Knoblauch, Chuck (Twins) | Franchise Player |
| Koufax, Sandy (Yankees) | Franchise Player |
| Larkin, Barry (Reds) | Franchise Player |
| Leclerc, Jose (Rangers) | free agent holders |
| Liddell, Earl (Mets) | Rookie/Prospect |
| Lowe, Brandon (Rays) | free agent holders |
| Lowe, Derek (Rangers) | Franchise Player |
| Maddux, Greg (Athletics) | Franchise Player |
| Marichal, Juan (Giants) | Franchise Player |
| Martinez, Pedro (Dodgers) | Franchise Player |
| Mathewson, Christy (Reds) | Franchise Player |
| Mathewson, Christy (Giants) | Franchise Player |
| Mauer, Joe (Twins) | Franchise Player |
| Mays, Willie (Giants) | Franchise Player |
| McCovey, Willie (Giants) | Franchise Player |
| McLain, Denny (Tigers) | Franchise Player |
| Mondesi, Raul (Dodgers) | choice rookie |
| Montefusco, John (loafers) | free agent holders |
| Morgan, Joe (Reds) | Franchise Player |
| Olerud, John (Mets) | Franchise Player |
| Olson, Matt (Athletics) | free agent holders |
| O'Neill, Tip (Athletics) | Franchise Player |
| Palmeiro, Rafael (Rangers) | Franchise Player |
| Peralta, Freddy (Brew Sounds) | Franchise Player |
| Piazza, Mike (Mets) | Franchise Player |
| Piazza, Mike (A'viators) | Franchise Player |
| Pineda, Michael (Mariners) | free agent holders |
| Pineiro, Joel (Mariners) | free agent holders |
| Pujols, Albert (Cardinals) | free agent holders |
| Reynolds, Bryan (PirateMarauders) | free agent holders |
| Rincon, Andy (Cardinals) | Franchise Player |
| Robinson, Frank (Reds) | Franchise Player |
| Rodriguez, Alex (Mariners) | Franchise Player |
| Ruth, Babe (Yankees) | Franchise Player |
| Sale, Chris (Dodgers) | Franchise Player |
| Santana, Johan (Pirates) | Franchise Player |
| Scherzer, Max (Tigers) | Franchise Player |
| Seaver, Tom (Reds) | Franchise Player |
| Severino, Luis (Yankees) | Franchise Player |
| Siegrist, Kevin (Cardinals) | free agent holders |
| Simmons, Al (White Sox) | Franchise Player |
| Simmons, Al (Mets) | Franchise Player |
| Snell, Blake (Rays) | Franchise Player |
| Sosa, Sammy (Rangers) | Franchise Player |
| Speaker, Tris (Tigers) | Franchise Player |
| Syndergaard, Noah (Mets) | choice rookie |
| Thomas, Frank (White Sox) | Franchise Player |
| Tiant, Luis (Yankees) | Franchise Player |
| Torres, Gleyber (Yankees) | free agent holders |
| Vaughan, Arky (Pirates) | Franchise Player |
| Verlander, Justin (Tigers) | Franchise Player |
| Wakefield, Dick (Tigers) | free agent holders |
| Walsh, Ed (White Sox) | Franchise Player |
| Waner, Paul (Pirates) | free agent holders |
| Williams, Jimmy (Cubs) | Franchise Player |
| Woodruff, Brandon (Brew Sounds) | Franchise Player |
| Wright, David (Mets) | Franchise Player |
| York, Rudy (Tigers) | free agent holders |
| Zobrist, Ben (Rays) | Franchise Player |
