Back to Boards

Very Good Players From the 90's


Very Good Players From the 90's

Hello Everyone,

My Hall of Very Good league uses a Veteran's Committee like system to add new players into the league. This season I am looking to add the best non-Hall of Fame players from the 90's. If you can think of a player that played at least 3 full seasons during the 1990's and is in the tier below hall of famer feel free to shout them out in this thread.

Any players you bring up that aren't already in the league will be added to our ballot. If you like this discussion you may be a good fit for the Hall of Very Good. See the rules below if you would like to join.

Thanks
Castle

League Rules:
https://www.pennantchase.com/lgRule..

Re: Very Good Players From the 90's

Cool idea. Here's a few.

C Benito Santiago
1B Mo Vaughn
2B Chuck Knoblauch
3B Robin Ventura
SS Tony Fernandez
OF Kenny Lofton (too good?)
OF Eric Davis
OF Albert Belle
SP Jose Rijo
SP Hideo Nomo
SP David Cone
RP Mitch Williams
RP John Wettleland
RP Armando Benitez

Re: Very Good Players From the 90's

Andruw Jones is HOF quality, but he isn't in (yet?).

Re: Very Good Players From the 90's

Lenny Dykstra

-Hey Now

Re: Re: Very Good Players From the 90's

There are a few guys mentioned that aren't already in so on the ballot they go. I'm curious to hear about what people thought of Joe Carter. I know he can be controversial between the old and new school mindset

Re: Very Good Players From the 90's

Mark Grace
Jamie Moyer

Re: Re: Very Good Players From the 90's

Joe Carter grades out as an average or below average starter most seasons. As a hitter, I could see the argument, but his defense was pretty bad most seasons. I would take Andy Van Slyke over Carter, but Van Slyke only had 3 seasons of at least 130 games in the 90's. Speaking of Pirates, Jay Bell was a very good defensive SS who held his own at the plate.

Re: Very Good Players From the 90's

1 for every position (Alot of Indians)

C - Sandy Alomar
1B - Cecil Fielder
2B - Bret Boone
SS - Omar Vizquel
3B - Matt Williams
OF - Manny
OF - Brian Giles
OF - Bernie Willams
SP - Dennis Martinez
RP - Rod Beck