| Player (Team) [team counts] | Tagged |
|---|
| Aybar, Willy (Mud Hens) | 4 Extra Seasons(max) |
| Baumgartner, Stan (Pilots) | 1 Extra Season |
| Bettis, Chad (Canadians) | 1 Extra Season |
| Blankenship, Lance (Generals) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Bodie, Ping (Isotopes) | 1 Extra Season |
| Bragg, Darren (Generals) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Burnett, A.J. (Generals) | 4 Extra Seasons(max) |
| Carreon, Mark (Canadians) | 1 Extra Season |
| Carter, Chris (Wingnuts) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Coscarart, Pete (Canadians) | 1 Extra Season |
| Counsell, Craig (Iced Teas) | 4 Extra Seasons(max) |
| DiMaggio, Vince (Ghost Players) | 1 Extra Season |
| Ducey, Rob (Charlie Browns) | 1 Extra Season |
| Duda, Lucas (Isotopes) | 1 Extra Season |
| Early, Jake (Isotopes) | 1 Extra Season |
| Garland, Jon (Isotopes) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Graffanino, Tony (Vixen) | 1 Extra Season |
| Greene, Khalil (Iced Teas) | 1 Extra Season |
| Grimm, Charlie (Silver Sox) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Grissom, Marv (Canadians) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Guzman, Juan (Vixen) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Gwynn Jr., Tony (Pilots) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Hendricks, Ellie (Peace Frogs) | 1 Extra Season |
| Hernandez, Jose (Silver Sox) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Hoffpauir, Micah (Isotopes) | 1 Extra Season |
| Jones, Jacque (Ghost Players) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Karp, Ryan (Generals) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Laga, Mike (Bananas) | 4 Extra Seasons(max) |
| Lewis, Darren (Knights) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Lidle, Cory (Charlie Browns) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Love, Slim (Knights) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Masaoka, Onan (Generals) | 1 Extra Season |
| Mazzilli, Lee (Peace Frogs) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Melton, Rube (Bananas) | 4 Extra Seasons(max) |
| Menechino, Frank (Peace Frogs) | 1 Extra Season |
| Milner, Eddie (Isotopes) | 1 Extra Season |
| Monbouquette, Bill (Charlie Browns) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Niedenfuer, Tom (Silver Sox) | 1 Extra Season |
| Nieves, Melvin (Chiefs) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Nolasco, Ricky (Silver Sox) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Parnell, Mel (Ghost Players) | 1 Extra Season |
| Piersall, Jim (Canadians) | 1 Extra Season |
| Rodriguez, Ellie (Generals) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Shinjo, Tsuyoshi (Silver Sox) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Turley, Bob (Isotopes) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Veras, Quilvio (Nine) | 3 Extra Seasons |
| Wallis, Joe (Peace Frogs) | 1 Extra Season |
| Wyckoff, Weldon (Chiefs) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Yabu, Keiichi (Iced Teas) | 1 Extra Season |
| Yost, Eddie (Pilots) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Young, Chris (Ghost Players) | 2 Extra Seasons |
| Zaun, Gregg (Canadians) | 4 Extra Seasons(max) |
