| Player (Team) [team counts] | Tagged |
|---|
| Alou, Moises (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Beckett, Josh (Maulers) | Keeper |
| Bell, David (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Berkman, Lance (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Cabrera, Miguel (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Cain, Matt (Aces) | No Drop |
| Carpenter, Chris (Jackrabbits) | Keeper |
| Carrasco, Hector (Jackrabbits) | Keeper |
| Castillo, Luis (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Clark, Tony (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Clemens, Roger (Aces) | No Drop |
| Counsell, Craig (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Crawford, Carl (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Drew, J.D. (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Duffy, Chris (Jackrabbits) | Keeper |
| Dunn, Adam (Hit Machine) | Keeper |
| Edmonds, Jim (Aces) | Keeper |
| Ellis, Mark (Aces) | Keeper |
| Ensberg, Morgan (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Escobar, Kelvim (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Everett, Adam (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Eyre, Scott (Jackrabbits) | Keeper |
| Figgins, Chone (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Freel, Ryan (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Fultz, Aaron (Aces) | No Drop |
| Gathright, Joey (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Giles, Brian (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Giles, Marcus (Fireballers) | Keeper |
| Gordon, Tom (Fireballers) | Keeper |
| Griffey Jr, Ken (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Grudzielanek, Mark (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Hall, Toby (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Halladay, Roy (Aces) | No Drop |
| Harden, Rich (Hit Machine) | Keeper |
| Helton, Todd (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Hensley, Clay (Aces) | Keeper |
| Hernandez, Felix (Aces) | No Drop |
| Howard, Ryan (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Howry, Bob (Aces) | No Drop |
| Jenkins, Geoff (Hit Machine) | Keeper |
| Jeter, Derek (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Johnson, Randy (Maulers) | Keeper |
| Jones, Todd (Hit Machine) | Keeper |
| Kent, Jeff (Leathermen) | Keeper |
| Konerko, Paul (Jackrabbits) | Keeper |
| Linebrink, Scott (Fireballers) | Keeper |
| Liriano, Francisco (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Luna, Hector (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Maholm, Paul (Aces) | Keeper |
| Martinez, Pedro (Aces) | No Drop |
| Martinez, Victor (Leathermen) | Keeper |
| Matsui, Hideki (Leathermen) | Keeper |
| Mauer, Joe (Leathermen) | Keeper |
| Medders, Brandon (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Michaels, Jason (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Myers, Brett (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Ozuna, Pablo (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Peavy, Jake (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Peralta, Jhonny (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Perez, Neifi (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Pettitte, Andy (Fireballers) | Keeper |
| Pierre, Juan (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Polanco, Placido (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Politte, Cliff (Aces) | No Drop |
| Prior, Mark (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Ramirez, Aramis (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Reyes, Jose (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Rhodes, Arthur (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Roberts, Dave (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Rodriguez, Francisco (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Rodriguez, Ivan (Jackrabbits) | Keeper |
| Rowand, Aaron (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Ryan, B.J. (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Sanders, Reggie (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Sexson, Richie (Hit Machine) | Keeper |
| Sheets, Ben (Aces) | Keeper |
| Sheffield, Gary (Fireballers) | Keeper |
| Sizemore, Grady (Maulers) | Keeper |
| Smoltz, John (Maulers) | Keeper |
| Speier, Justin (Aces) | No Drop |
| Street, Huston (Aces) | No Drop |
| Suzuki, Ichiro (Jackrabbits) | No Drop |
| Taveras, Willy (Leathermen) | No Drop |
| Teixeira, Mark (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Tejada, Miguel (Hit Machine) | Keeper |
| Turnbow, Derrick (Maulers) | Keeper |
| Utley, Chase (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Valentin, Javier (Maulers) | No Drop |
| Valverde, Jose (Fireballers) | No Drop |
| Varitek, Jason (Aces) | Keeper |
| Walker, Larry (Leathermen) | Keeper |
| Willis, Dontrelle (Maulers) | Keeper |
| Wright, David (Hit Machine) | No Drop |
| Young, Michael (Fireballers) | Keeper |
| Zambrano, Carlos (Leathermen) | Keeper |
| Zaun, Gregg (Leathermen) | No Drop |
The Ultimate Test 2005
