| Player (Team) | Tagged |
|---|
| Arndt, Harry (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Bailey, Harvey (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Barrett, Jimmy (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Barry, Shad (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Bay, Harry (Reds) | Rookie |
| Bealman, Carter (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Beck, Erve (Blues) | Rookie |
| Bendrick, Jack (Giants) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Bradley, Bill (Blues) | Rookie |
| Brain, Dave (White Sox) | Rookie |
| Bresnahan, Roger (Orioles) | Rookie |
| Bresnahan, Codger (Giants) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Brown, Jorge (Giants) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Burkett, Messy (Brewers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Carney, Pat (Beaneaters) | Rookie |
| Chance, Frank (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Clarke, Fred (Pirates) | Rookie |
| Coakley, Andy (Athletics) | Rookie |
| Conroy, Sid (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Conroy, Wid (Brewers) | Rookie |
| Cooley, Duff (Beaneaters) | Rookie |
| Corbett, Joe (Orioles) | Rookie |
| Coughlin, Bill (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Crawford, Sam (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Cronin, Max (Orioles) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Cross, Marty (Athletics) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Currie, Clarence (Reds) | Rookie |
| Currie, Vance (Cardinals) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Daly, Dom (White Sox) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Damon, Lefty (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Davidson, George (White Sox) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Davis, Harry (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Delahanty, Jim (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Delahanty, James (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Delahanty, Eddie (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Dexter, Chuckie (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Dinneen, William (Beaneaters) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Donahue, Jiggs (Pirates) | Rookie |
| Donahue, Blue (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Donahue, Riggs (Brewers) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Donlin, Mike (Orioles) | Rookie |
| Donlin, Mickey (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Dooin, Red (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Dowling, Pete (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Dowling, Paul (Blues) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Drill, Louie (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Duggleby, Willie (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Dunham, Wiley (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Durham, John (White Sox) | Rookie |
| Eason, Malachi (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Eason, Mal (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Egan, Wish (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Ellis, Bones (Pirates) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Ely, Jones (Senators) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Evans, Ray (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Evers, Johnny (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Farrell, John (Senators) | Rookie |
| Farrell, Ron (Cardinals) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Fields, Tom (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Fleck, Eli (Athletics) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Fleck, Merv (Reds) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Flick, Elmer (Phillies) | Rookie |
| Flick, Edwin (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Foreman, Freddie (Americans) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Foster, Pop (White Sox) | Rookie |
| Foster, Peter (Senators) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Foyle, Jake (Giants) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Frazier, Chuck (Phillies) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Friend, Danny (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Gartley, Ned (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Garvin, Nick (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Gettman, Jake (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Gilbert, Telly (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Gochnauer, Vaughn (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Green, Danny (Orphans) | Rookie |
| Green, Dennis (White Sox) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Hahn, Noodles (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Hampstead, Charles (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Hardy, Alex (Orphans) | Rookie |
| Harland, Duck (Tigers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Harper, Jack (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Hartman, Ted (Cardinals) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Hartzel, Nipsy (Athletics) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Harvey, Rajah (Blues) | Two-Way Player, Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Harvey, Rajah (Blues) | Two-Way Player, Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Harvey, Zaza (White Sox) | Two-Way Player, Rookie |
| Harvey, Zaza (White Sox) | Two-Way Player, Rookie |
| Haslund, Bert (Athletics) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Hay, Barry (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Hayden, Jack (Athletics) | Rookie |
| Heidrick, Emmet (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Heimlich, Everett (Brewers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Heismann, Crese (Orioles) | Rookie |
| Hemphill, Chadwick (Brewers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Hickman, Charlie (Real Prog.) | Two-Way Player |
| Hickman, Charlie (Senators) | Two-Way Player |
| Hicks, Charles (Tigers) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Hill, Bill (Beaneaters) | Rookie |
| Hobbs, Johnny (Beaneaters) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Hoffman, Larry (Brewers) | Rookie |
| Houston, Bertram (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Howell, Harry (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Howell, Jack (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Hoy, Smartypants (Reds) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Hughes, Timmy (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Hughes, Tom (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Husting, Bert (Brewers) | Rookie |
| Irvin, Chuck (Superbas) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Jackson, Harper (Brewers) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Johnson, Abbie (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Jones, Davy (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Jones, David (Orphans) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Jordan, Tim (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Joss, Addie (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Kehoe, Mark (Orphans) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Keister, Brill (Senators) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Kelley, Mike (Superbas) | Rookie |
| Kelley, Jeremiah (Reds) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Kelly, Joseph (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Kennedy, Lumberyard (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Krueger, Otto (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| LaChance, Napoleon (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| LaVance, Andy (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Leach, Tommy (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Learnhard, Bill (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Lee, Watty (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Leonard, Tom (Athletics) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Long, Red (Beaneaters) | Rookie |
| Lowell, Robbie (Giants) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Lundgren, Carl (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Malone, Timmy (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Maloney, Billy (Brewers) | Rookie |
| Mathewson, Christy (Giants) | Rookie |
| Mathison, Jimmy (Beaneaters) | Rookie |
| McCain, Brant (Orioles) | Renamed Duplicate |
| McCann, Grant (Giants) | Renamed Duplicate |
| McDonald, Larry (Brewers) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| McFarland, Frederick (White Sox) | Renamed Duplicate |
| McFarris, Herm (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| McGinnity, John Paul (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| McGuire, David (Tigers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| McIntyre, Matty (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| McJames, Doc (Superbas) | Rookie |
| McMahon, John (Giants) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| McMakin, John (Superbas) | Rookie |
| McMillan, Sam (Tigers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Mercer, Wade (Tigers) | Two-Way Player, Renamed Duplicate |
| Mercer, Win (Senators) | Two-Way Player |
| Mercer, Wade (Tigers) | Two-Way Player, Renamed Duplicate |
| Mercer, Win (Senators) | Two-Way Player |
| Merritt, George (Pirates) | Rookie |
| Miller, Roscoe (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Miller, Ross (Giants) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Mitchell, Fred (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Mitchell, Greg (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Moore, Earl (Blues) | Rookie |
| Mullin, George (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Murphy, Deacon (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Murphy, Ed (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Nance, Doc (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Newton, Jacques (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Newton, Doc (Reds) | Rookie |
| Nops, Jerry (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| O'Brien, Pete (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| O'Heny, Ted (Orioles) | Renamed Duplicate |
| O'Neill, Mike (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Owen, Frank (Tigers) | Rookie |
| Parks, Sully (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Pearson, Alex (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Phelps, Ed (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Platt, Riley (White Sox) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Pond, Arlie (Giants) | Rookie |
| Poole, Ned (Reds) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Rhoads, Bob (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Richardson, Bill (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Roman, Jack (Giants) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Schlafly, Larry (Orphans) | Rookie |
| Schreck, Curve (Tigers) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Schreckengost, Henry (Blues) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Schreckengost, Augie (Athletics) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Scott, Dick (White Sox) | Rookie |
| Seagram, Ty (Real Prog.) | Two-Way Player, Renamed Duplicate |
| Seagram, Ty (Reds) | Two-Way Player, Renamed Duplicate |
| Sebring, Jimmy (Pirates) | Rookie |
| Seymour, Cy (Real Prog.) | Two-Way Player |
| Seymour, Cy (Real Prog.) | Two-Way Player |
| Shay, Danny (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Sheckard, Jimmy (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Shepard, Jamie (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Shields, Charlie (Brewers) | Rookie |
| Skopec, John (White Sox) | Rookie |
| Slagle, Remy (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Smith, Henry (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Smith, Kip (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Smith, Charlie (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Smoot, Homer (Cardinals) | Rookie |
| Sparks, Terry (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Steele, Jimmy (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Stivetts, Jack (Brewers) | Two-Way Player |
| Stivetts, Jack (Brewers) | Two-Way Player |
| Strang, Stevie (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Strang, Sammy (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Strong, Stewie (Orphans) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Sudhoff, Rickey (Brewers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Sugden, John (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Swaim, Cy (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Swormstedt, Len (Reds) | Rookie |
| Tannehill, Jesse (Pirates) | Two-Way Player |
| Tannehill, Jesse (Pirates) | Two-Way Player |
| Taylor, Moron (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Thielman, Harold (Giants) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Thoney, Jack (Orioles) | Rookie |
| Thoney, Jason (Blues) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Thornton, Walter (Superbas) | Rookie |
| Thorpe, Cal (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Tinker, Joe (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Townsend, Pappy (Senators) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Townsend, Happy (Phillies) | Rookie |
| Turner, Tuck (Orphans) | Rookie |
| Van Patton, Dick (Brewers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Vorhees, Cedric (Senators) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Waddell, Red (Athletics) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Waddell, Rube (Pirates) | Rookie |
| Wagner, Heinie (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Wall, Irving (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Wallace, Mikey (Brewers) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Warner-Hicks, John (Real Prog.) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Weismann, Creed (Reds) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| White, Doc (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Wilson, Highball (Athletics) | Rookie |
| Wiltse, Spider (Athletics) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Winter, George (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Winters, Rube (Real Prog.) | Rookie, Renamed Duplicate |
| Wolf, Barry (Senators) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Woods, Walt (Phillies) | Rookie |
| Wright, Gene (Superbas) | Rookie |
| Wrigley, Zeke (Real Prog.) | Rookie |
| Yance, Clintock (Beaneaters) | Renamed Duplicate |
| Yerkes, Ian (Orioles) | Renamed Duplicate |