| Day 15 |
| Liberty University Cabana Boys12-2 D. Chance, R (3-0, 2.78 ERA) | | | 1919 Chicago Black Sox6-8 E. Cicotte, R (1-1, 3.25 ERA) |
| 2004 Boston Red Sox7-7 C. Schilling, R (0-1, 3.91 ERA) | | | 1927 New York Yankees6-8 L. Gomez, L (3-0, 1.40 ERA) |
| 2001 Seattle Mariners4-10 A. Sele, R (0-1, 6.92 ERA) | | | Asheville Hellbenders9-5 W. Ford, L (2-0, 3.77 ERA) |
| 1920 Cleveland Guardians5-9 D. Mails, L (0-3, 5.23 ERA) | | | 1984 Detroit Tigers5-9 M. Fidrych, R (1-1, 3.65 ERA) |
| 1962 San Francisco Giants6-8 B. O'Dell, L (0-1, 4.15 ERA) | | | 2025 Phinney Ridgebacks8-6 J. Bush, R (1-0, 1.59 ERA) |
| 1909 Pittsburgh Pirates5-9 L. Leifield, L (1-0, 1.72 ERA) | | | 1906 Chicago Cubs7-7 J. Taylor, R (0-1, 4.80 ERA) |
| 1998 San Diego Padres8-6 A. Ashby, R (2-0, 1.72 ERA) | | | 1944 St. Louis Cardinals6-8 H. Brecheen, L (0-2, 5.54 ERA) |
| 1953 Brooklyn Dodgers5-9 R. Meyer, R (0-1, 5.06 ERA) | | | 1975 Cincinnati Reds11-3 P. Darcy, R (0-0, 1.93 ERA) |
| 1976 Philadelphia Phillies7-7 L. Christenson, R (0-2, 14.21 ERA) | | | 1930 Philadelphia Athletics3-11 B. Shores, R (1-1, 6.10 ERA) |
| 1985 Kansas City Royals7-7 D. Jackson, L (1-0, 2.51 ERA) | | | 2019 Houston Astros8-6 B. Peacock, R (0-2, 12.00 ERA) |
| 1998 Atlanta Braves8-6 D. Neagle, L (1-0, 3.86 ERA) | | | East Atlanta Crackhouse Gang10-4 D. Lemaster, L (1-0, 7.00 ERA) |
| Rockbridge Rapids9-5 R. Curry, R (1-0, 3.10 ERA) | | | 1969 Baltimore Orioles6-8 M. Cuellar, L (0-3, 5.31 ERA) |
| Day 16 |
| 1944 St. Louis Cardinals6-8 R. Munger, R (1-2, 5.40 ERA) | | | 1962 San Francisco Giants6-8 J. Antonelli, L (2-1, 4.37 ERA) |
| 1969 Baltimore Orioles6-8 T. Phoebus, R (0-2, 8.64 ERA) | | | 2004 Boston Red Sox7-7 T. Wakefield, R (1-0, 5.00 ERA) |
| Rockbridge Rapids9-5 D. Cardwell, R (1-1, 5.02 ERA) | | | 1927 New York Yankees6-8 U. Shocker, R (1-1, 5.11 ERA) |
| 1985 Kansas City Royals7-7 B. Saberhagen, R (2-1, 1.90 ERA) | | | Asheville Hellbenders9-5 C. Swan, R (2-1, 1.50 ERA) |
| Liberty University Cabana Boys12-2 M. Soto, R (0-0, 3.65 ERA) | | | 1984 Detroit Tigers5-9 J. Morris, R (0-2, 7.00 ERA) |
| 1930 Philadelphia Athletics3-11 L. Grove, L (0-2, 5.94 ERA) | | | 1998 Atlanta Braves8-6 G. Maddux, R (0-2, 5.66 ERA) |
| 2019 Houston Astros8-6 J. Verlander, R (2-1, 0.79 ERA) | | | 2001 Seattle Mariners4-10 F. Garcia, R (0-3, 4.34 ERA) |
| 1919 Chicago Black Sox6-8 R. Russell, L (2-1, 1.69 ERA) | | | 1920 Cleveland Guardians5-9 S. Coveleski, R (1-2, 3.97 ERA) |
| 1998 San Diego Padres8-6 K. Brown, R (1-2, 5.79 ERA) | | | 2025 Phinney Ridgebacks8-6 R. Clemens, R (2-1, 4.42 ERA) |
| 1906 Chicago Cubs7-7 J. Pfiester, L (1-2, 0.68 ERA) | | | 1953 Brooklyn Dodgers5-9 C. Erskine, R (0-0, 4.32 ERA) |
| 1909 Pittsburgh Pirates5-9 B. Adams, R (0-0, 0.42 ERA) | | | 1975 Cincinnati Reds11-3 D. Gullett, L (1-1, 4.57 ERA) |
| 1976 Philadelphia Phillies7-7 S. Carlton, L (1-1, 4.95 ERA) | | | East Atlanta Crackhouse Gang10-4 S. Koufax, L (3-0, 2.67 ERA) |
| Day 17 |
| 1944 St. Louis Cardinals6-8 T. Wilks, R (2-1, 2.00 ERA) | | | 1962 San Francisco Giants6-8 B. Pierce, L (0-1, 3.15 ERA) |
| 1969 Baltimore Orioles6-8 J. Palmer, R (2-1, 3.47 ERA) | | | 2004 Boston Red Sox7-7 P. Martinez, R (2-0, 1.25 ERA) |
| Rockbridge Rapids9-5 M. Russo, L (0-2, 2.95 ERA) | | | 1927 New York Yankees6-8 W. Moore, R (0-2, 7.11 ERA) |
| 1985 Kansas City Royals7-7 C. Leibrandt, L (1-1, 4.15 ERA) | | | Asheville Hellbenders9-5 G. Brunet, L (2-0, 3.52 ERA) |
| Liberty University Cabana Boys12-2 A. Leiter, L (1-0, 3.14 ERA) | | | 1984 Detroit Tigers5-9 M. Wilcox, R (1-0, 4.50 ERA) |
| 1930 Philadelphia Athletics3-11 E. Rommel, R (0-1, 4.05 ERA) | | | 1998 Atlanta Braves8-6 P. Byrd, R (2-1, 1.14 ERA) |
| 2019 Houston Astros8-6 G. Cole, R (2-1, 1.82 ERA) | | | 2001 Seattle Mariners4-10 J. Moyer, L (0-2, 6.87 ERA) |
| 1919 Chicago Black Sox6-8 G. Lowdermilk, R (0-2, 7.27 ERA) | | | 1920 Cleveland Guardians5-9 E. Myers, R (0-0, 3.48 ERA) |
| 1998 San Diego Padres8-6 J. Peavy, R (0-1, 9.24 ERA) | | | 2025 Phinney Ridgebacks8-6 D. Vance, R (2-1, 4.35 ERA) |
| 1906 Chicago Cubs7-7 M. Brown, R (1-2, 5.57 ERA) | | | 1953 Brooklyn Dodgers5-9 R. Branca, R (1-2, 4.50 ERA) |
| 1909 Pittsburgh Pirates5-9 H. Camnitz, R (1-2, 4.43 ERA) | | | 1975 Cincinnati Reds11-3 G. Nolan, R (3-0, 4.03 ERA) |
| 1976 Philadelphia Phillies7-7 J. Lonborg, R (1-2, 2.28 ERA) | | | East Atlanta Crackhouse Gang10-4 K. Forsch, R (2-1, 4.13 ERA) |