| Day 16 |
| Toledo Blue Stockings9-6 F. Hernandez, R (1-1, 8.16 ERA) | | | Chicago Bears9-6 R. Johnson, L (1-1, 6.06 ERA) |
| Burnham Ol' Joes6-9 R. Clemens, R (2-1, 4.58 ERA) | | | San Diego Sharks7-8 P. Martinez, R (0-1, 6.11 ERA) |
| Louisiana Gators7-8 J. Santana, L (1-2, 5.91 ERA) | | | Dallas Mustangs8-7 F. Liriano, L (1-1, 1.69 ERA) |
| Chicago Reapers9-6 K. Brown, R (1-1, 4.74 ERA) | | | Denver Eagles5-10 R. Harden, R (2-0, 4.11 ERA) |
| Dungeon Dragons10-5 T. Lincecum, R (2-0, 2.19 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder4-11 C. Schilling, R (1-1, 4.71 ERA) |
| Uniontown Brown10-5 J. Schmidt, R (1-1, 9.45 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs6-9 B. Sheets, R (0-3, 5.49 ERA) |
| Day 17 |
| Toledo Blue Stockings9-6 E. Bedard, L (0-1, 10.03 ERA) | | | Chicago Bears9-6 J. Vazquez, R (0-1, 5.59 ERA) |
| Burnham Ol' Joes6-9 J. Peavy, R (0-1, 4.64 ERA) | | | San Diego Sharks7-8 J. Moyer, L (2-1, 3.93 ERA) |
| Louisiana Gators7-8 C. Young, R (2-1, 5.79 ERA) | | | Dallas Mustangs8-7 C. Carpenter, R (0-0, 23.82 ERA) |
| Chicago Reapers9-6 M. Mussina, R (1-1, 5.49 ERA) | | | Denver Eagles5-10 A. Pettitte, L (1-1, 6.88 ERA) |
| Dungeon Dragons10-5 D. Lowe, R (2-0, 4.95 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder4-11 D. Haren, R (1-1, 4.24 ERA) |
| Uniontown Brown10-5 J. Weaver, R (1-1, 6.61 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs6-9 R. Halladay, R (0-0, 3.47 ERA) |
| Day 18 |
| Toledo Blue Stockings9-6 C. Zambrano, R (0-1, 4.15 ERA) | | | Chicago Bears9-6 J. Duchscherer, R (2-0, 0.84 ERA) |
| Burnham Ol' Joes6-9 C. Hamels, L (0-3, 5.89 ERA) | | | San Diego Sharks7-8 T. Wakefield, R (0-0, 3.55 ERA) |
| Louisiana Gators7-8 R. Wolf, L (0-1, 7.88 ERA) | | | Dallas Mustangs8-7 O. Perez, L (1-1, 3.86 ERA) |
| Chicago Reapers9-6 J. Beckett, R (1-1, 6.75 ERA) | | | Denver Eagles5-10 R. Nolasco, R (1-0, 2.57 ERA) |
| Dungeon Dragons10-5 T. Hudson, R (1-2, 8.24 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder4-11 W. Alvarez, L (0-2, 6.00 ERA) |
| Uniontown Brown10-5 Z. Greinke, R (2-0, 2.45 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs6-9 K. Wood, R (2-1, 4.58 ERA) |