| Day 42 |
| New York Mets18-23 C. Hamels, L (2-5, 5.43 ERA) | | | Brooklyn Bulldogs24-17 A. Nola, R (4-4, 3.67 ERA) |
| Bronx Butt Munchers23-18 J. Lester, L (5-2, 2.04 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs18-23 M. Harvey, R (1-4, 6.84 ERA) |
| New York Bombas24-17 D. Hudson, R (2-3, 4.29 ERA) | | | Toronto Tigers21-20 C. Buchholz, R (4-4, 5.30 ERA) |
| Florida Pythons23-18 F. Hernandez, R (5-1, 3.53 ERA) | | | Arizona Suns22-19 M. Bumgarner, L (4-2, 4.50 ERA) |
| Atlanta Gorillas18-23 M. Clevinger, R (1-5, 5.06 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares23-18 L. Giolito, R (5-0, 2.05 ERA) |
| NJ Smells14-27 C. Sale, L (2-6, 8.60 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders18-23 K. Hendricks, R (4-2, 4.47 ERA) |
| Day 43 |
| Atlanta Gorillas18-23 J. Shields, R (3-3, 4.64 ERA) | | | New York Bombas24-17 Y. Darvish, R (3-4, 3.95 ERA) |
| Charlotte Spiders18-23 M. Tanaka, R (2-4, 5.82 ERA) | | | Bronx Butt Munchers23-18 C. Kershaw, L (4-3, 6.22 ERA) |
| Utah Nightmares23-18 R. Ray, L (4-1, 2.98 ERA) | | | New York Mets18-23 W. Buehler, R (3-3, 4.47 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns22-19 A. Wood, L (1-4, 8.44 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs18-23 H. Iwakuma, R (1-6, 9.49 ERA) |
| Brooklyn Bulldogs24-17 S. Strasburg, R (1-5, 7.46 ERA) | | | NJ Smells14-27 C. Carrasco, R (1-3, 6.51 ERA) |
| Toronto Tigers21-20 M. Cain, R (4-2, 4.47 ERA) | | | Florida Pythons23-18 J. Cueto, R (4-2, 2.43 ERA) |
| Day 44 |
| Atlanta Gorillas18-23 R. Porcello, R (2-3, 6.94 ERA) | | | New York Bombas24-17 G. Richards, R (5-2, 4.61 ERA) |
| Charlotte Spiders18-23 S. Gray, R (1-2, 4.60 ERA) | | | Bronx Butt Munchers23-18 P. Corbin, L (1-0, 3.99 ERA) |
| Utah Nightmares23-18 G. Gonzalez, L (1-4, 6.47 ERA) | | | New York Mets18-23 L. Severino, R (2-3, 9.23 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns22-19 D. Haren, R (2-3, 4.83 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs18-23 L. Castillo, R (0-4, 6.29 ERA) |
| Brooklyn Bulldogs24-17 R. Oswalt, R (3-2, 4.80 ERA) | | | NJ Smells14-27 D. Keuchel, L (0-3, 7.13 ERA) |
| Toronto Tigers21-20 J. Paxton, L (4-2, 6.98 ERA) | | | Florida Pythons23-18 M. Foltynewicz, R (5-1, 3.04 ERA) |