| Day 1 |
| Louisville Colonels0-0 A. Rusie, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | New York Metropolitans0-0 J. Whitney, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Brooklyn Grays0-0 J. McCormick, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | St. Paul Saints0-0 T. Larkin, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Brooklyn Atlantics0-0 C. Buffinton, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Philadelphia Athletics0-0 K. Madden, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Indianapolis Hoosiers0-0 E. Cushman, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Chicago Browns0-0 J. Ward, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Louisville Colonels0-0 T. Ramsey, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | New York Metropolitans0-0 B. Hutchison, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Brooklyn Grays0-0 H. O'Day, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | St. Paul Saints0-0 C. Petty, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Brooklyn Atlantics0-0 R. Ehret, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Philadelphia Athletics0-0 E. Smith, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Indianapolis Hoosiers0-0 E. Cushman, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Chicago Browns0-0 C. Radbourn, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 3 |
| Brooklyn Grays0-0 J. Devlin, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | St. Paul Saints0-0 T. Larkin, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Brooklyn Atlantics0-0 A. Terry, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Philadelphia Athletics0-0 L. Baldwin, L (0-0, - ERA) |