| Day 1 |
| Boston Reds84-76 J. Maloney, R (14-14, 4.38 ERA) | | | Chicago Dodgers71-83 D. Drysdale, R (12-10, 3.43 ERA) |
| Oakland Pirates62-92 O. Pena, R (5-21, 6.10 ERA) | | | New York Colt 45's80-81 A. Downing, L (16-11, 3.89 ERA) |
| Detroit Braves93-73 J. Bunning, R (16-13, 4.33 ERA) | | | Cleveland Giants67-87 J. Marichal, R (12-12, 4.14 ERA) |
| Baltimore Phillies76-78 W. Bunker, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Minnesota Cardinals102-65 D. Siebler, R (15-10, 2.81 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Boston Reds84-76 J. Tsitouris, R (14-14, 3.82 ERA) | | | Chicago Dodgers71-83 S. Koufax, L (8-11, 4.27 ERA) |
| Oakland Pirates62-92 B. Friend, R (12-13, 4.01 ERA) | | | New York Colt 45's80-81 T. Farrell, R (9-16, 4.33 ERA) |
| Detroit Braves93-73 B. Sadowski, R (1-1, 1.65 ERA) | | | Cleveland Giants67-87 D. Donovan, R (12-12, 4.30 ERA) |
| Baltimore Phillies76-78 C. Short, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Minnesota Cardinals102-65 B. Gibson, R (11-14, 4.35 ERA) |