| Day 1 |
| 1889 Lou Colonels42-94 M. Scott, R (11-18, 3.92 ERA) | | | 1939 STL Browns61-77 W. Johnson, R (15-11, 3.42 ERA) |
| 1899 Cle Spiders84-66 E. Walsh, R (21-13, 3.63 ERA) | | | 1904 Wash Senators65-73 J. Arrieta, R (13-12, 3.02 ERA) |
| 1952 Pit Pirates74-68 S. Koufax, L (14-14, 3.44 ERA) | | | 2018 Balt Orioles82-61 L. Tiant, R (19-12, 3.15 ERA) |
| 1883 Phi Quakers73-68 C. Kershaw, L (14-12, 3.67 ERA) | | | 2003 Det Tigers69-73 C. Koonce, R (9-11, 4.23 ERA) |
| 1890 Pit Alleghenys65-71 B. Gibson, R (9-17, 3.92 ERA) | | | 1932 Bos Red Sox70-74 J. Santana, L (17-9, 3.29 ERA) |
| 1962 NY Mets78-64 P. Alexander, R (14-16, 3.22 ERA) | | | 2013 Hou Astros89-63 R. Ford, R (18-14, 3.43 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| 1889 Lou Colonels42-94 J. Marichal, R (11-9, 4.34 ERA) | | | 1939 STL Browns61-77 C. Mathewson, R (10-19, 4.48 ERA) |
| 1899 Cle Spiders84-66 E. Cicotte, R (13-9, 3.43 ERA) | | | 1904 Wash Senators65-73 V. Blue, L (11-14, 4.19 ERA) |
| 1952 Pit Pirates74-68 B. Singer, R (9-7, 4.52 ERA) | | | 2018 Balt Orioles82-61 C. Kluber, R (17-12, 4.03 ERA) |
| 1883 Phi Quakers73-68 C. Sweeney, R (15-10, 3.76 ERA) | | | 2003 Det Tigers69-73 J. Bonderman, R (8-7, 4.23 ERA) |
| 1890 Pit Alleghenys65-71 G. Cole, R (13-11, 3.91 ERA) | | | 1932 Bos Red Sox70-74 L. Baldwin, L (12-17, 4.63 ERA) |
| 1962 NY Mets78-64 J. Verlander, R (13-12, 3.18 ERA) | | | 2013 Hou Astros89-63 F. Smith, R (0-0, - ERA) |