Favorite Teams leagues are not included in Single-Season records. Records only remain for 10 seasons.
1. Duffy, Hugh Deadball Cubans 25
2. Meyerle, Levi Roanoke Renegades 25
3. Meyerle, Levi San Francisco Gunslingers 24
4. Anson, Cap Oyster Bay Eagles 24
5. Milligan, Jocko Loudoun Black Bears 24
6. Orr, Dave Walken Dead Ballers 23
7. Orr, Dave Moncton Rockets 23
8. McVey, Cal Pittsburgh Pirates 23
9. McVey, Cal Loudoun Black Bears 23
10. McVey, Cal Highland Park Highlanders 23
11. Simmons, Al Cal Bears 23
12. Anson, Cap Loudoun Black Bears 22
13. Tiernan, Mike CONGO LIONS 22
14. Anson, Cap Atlanta Survivors 22
15. Simmons, Al Glengary Grays 22
16. Dickey, Bill Dakota Autumn 22
17. Milligan, Jocko Fielding In the Deadball era 22
18. Delahanty, Ed Montreal Expos 22
19. Thompson, Sam Brampton Bulldogs 22
20. McKean, Ed St. Paul Saints 22
21. Holliday, Bug Chesapeake Oysters 21
22. Stenzel, Jake Iowa Corn Pickers 21
23. Lowe, Bobby Riverton River Bandits 21
24. Davis, George Bayside Tigers 21
25. Musial, Stan Columbus Colonials 21
26. Bannon, Jimmy Great Lakes Base Swippers 21
27. Williams, Jimmy GLOBEX Corporation 21
28. Browning, Pete New York Giants 21
29. Duffy, Hugh Vallejo Stars 21
30. Davis, George Battle Creek Cereal Kings 21
31. Baker, Frank A Baseball Team 21
32. Dahlen, Bill Parfittown Miners 21
33. Sheckard, Jimmy Buffalo Sabotage Dogs 21
34. Cravath, Gavvy Skye Highlanders 21
35. Duffy, Hugh Great Lakes Base Swippers 21
36. Crawford, Sam Munchin' Muff-ins 21
37. Orr, Dave Hazleton Pneumoconiosis 21
38. Delahanty, Ed Zephyrhills wizards 21
39. Milligan, Jocko Puzley Croswerdes 21
40. Thompson, Sam Kingston Cobras 21
41. Thompson, Sam Rockport Appleseeds 21
42. Orr, Dave Carolina Pirates 20
43. Duffy, Hugh Roanoke Renegades 20
44. Barnes, Ross Panama Canal Builders 20
45. Stenzel, Jake Bradenton Bees 20
46. Delahanty, Ed Vallejo Stars 20
47. Tiernan, Mike Bradenton Bees 20
48. Hornsby, Rogers Galena Leadheads 20
49. Duffy, Hugh G.O.B.’s Bananagrabbers 20
50. DiMaggio, Joe MYSTIC MAGIC 20