| Day 35 |
| Iowa Corn Pickers19-15 S. Kazmir, L (0-3, 7.34 ERA) | | | Roosevelt Rhubarbs18-16 B. Penny, R (1-5, 6.53 ERA) |
| Salem Demons15-19 J. Marquis, R (1-1, 4.45 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder21-13 J. Guthrie, R (0-0, 3.54 ERA) |
| Miskatonic Shoggoths14-20 P. Maholm, L (1-2, 4.86 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders17-17 J. Francis, L (2-2, 4.10 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns13-21 C. Silva, R (3-3, 7.52 ERA) | | | Freehold Yankees20-14 C. Schilling, R (0-3, 7.06 ERA) |
| Chicago Scooters21-13 D. Matsuzaka, R (3-0, 3.99 ERA) | | | Texas Outlaws21-13 B. Looper, R (3-1, 5.16 ERA) |
| Kansas Grasshoppers13-21 R. Wolf, L (1-2, 9.13 ERA) | | | Sacramento Lions12-22 C. James, L (1-3, 8.54 ERA) |
| Day Off: Pittsburgh Plunder |
| Day 36 |
| Iowa Corn Pickers19-15 C. Young, R (3-2, 2.61 ERA) | | | Roosevelt Rhubarbs18-16 E. Bedard, L (1-2, 3.61 ERA) |
| Salem Demons15-19 J. Shields, R (4-2, 2.06 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder21-13 J. Beckett, R (0-2, 4.91 ERA) |
| Miskatonic Shoggoths14-20 J. Peavy, R (2-3, 4.05 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders17-17 O. Hernandez, R (4-1, 2.45 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns13-21 T. Lilly, L (0-4, 4.39 ERA) | | | Freehold Yankees20-14 J. Santana, L (2-3, 5.57 ERA) |
| Chicago Scooters21-13 C. Hamels, L (3-2, 4.05 ERA) | | | Texas Outlaws21-13 J. Vazquez, R (4-2, 4.22 ERA) |
| Kansas Grasshoppers13-21 R. Hill, L (2-2, 3.61 ERA) | | | Sacramento Lions12-22 A. Harang, R (3-3, 2.60 ERA) |
| Day 37 |
| Texas Outlaws21-13 B. Bannister, R (1-1, 3.77 ERA) | | | Iowa Corn Pickers19-15 J. Verlander, R (2-4, 3.98 ERA) |
| Freehold Yankees20-14 B. Webb, R (3-1, 3.74 ERA) | | | Miskatonic Shoggoths14-20 F. Carmona, R (2-3, 3.72 ERA) |
| Sacramento Lions12-22 C. Sabathia, L (2-5, 6.35 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders17-17 J. Bergmann, R (0-2, 4.38 ERA) |
| Roosevelt Rhubarbs18-16 S. Hill, R (5-2, 3.62 ERA) | | | Arizona Suns13-21 O. Perez, L (3-2, 3.95 ERA) |
| Chicago Scooters21-13 T. Lincecum, R (4-2, 1.82 ERA) | | | Salem Demons15-19 D. Lowe, R (1-5, 3.95 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Plunder21-13 A. Burnett, R (2-1, 5.45 ERA) | | | Kansas Grasshoppers13-21 S. Marcum, R (0-3, 9.00 ERA) |