| Day 40 |
| ARKANSAS GATORS20-19 B. Dinneen, R (1-2, 4.24 ERA) | | | Texas Outlaws20-19 R. Waddell, L (2-3, 4.38 ERA) |
| Charlotte Spiders23-16 C. Bender, R (3-2, 4.00 ERA) | | | San Diego Sharks23-16 R. Ford, R (3-3, 4.62 ERA) |
| St. Brendan's Blue Jays23-16 A. Nola, R (3-1, 4.53 ERA) | | | Chicago Reapers18-21 R. Caldwell, R (2-0, 3.47 ERA) |
| Newark Eagles22-17 D. Leonard, L (4-2, 3.69 ERA) | | | Phoenix Dragons20-19 H. Camnitz, R (4-1, 6.19 ERA) |
| Kentucky Horses16-23 S. Coveleski, R (2-3, 6.23 ERA) | | | Homestead Grays19-20 C. Hendrix, R (3-1, 3.46 ERA) |
| Toledo Blue Stockings15-24 S. Fernandez, L (2-2, 6.45 ERA) | | | Reno Buffalo15-24 Z. Greinke, R (3-3, 6.63 ERA) |
| Day Off: St. Brendan's Blue Jays |
| Day 41 |
| ARKANSAS GATORS20-19 M. Scherzer, R (4-4, 4.20 ERA) | | | Texas Outlaws20-19 P. Martinez, R (2-6, 5.63 ERA) |
| Charlotte Spiders23-16 D. McNally, L (4-4, 2.42 ERA) | | | San Diego Sharks23-16 W. Johnson, R (6-1, 2.19 ERA) |
| St. Brendan's Blue Jays23-16 S. Koufax, L (4-1, 3.36 ERA) | | | Chicago Reapers18-21 J. Verlander, R (2-4, 3.32 ERA) |
| Newark Eagles22-17 R. Guidry, L (3-4, 3.81 ERA) | | | Phoenix Dragons20-19 L. Tiant, R (5-3, 4.29 ERA) |
| Kentucky Horses16-23 C. Sale, L (2-3, 4.84 ERA) | | | Homestead Grays19-20 C. Kershaw, L (4-3, 4.53 ERA) |
| Toledo Blue Stockings15-24 J. deGrom, R (3-4, 5.36 ERA) | | | Reno Buffalo15-24 D. Kile, R (2-2, 4.96 ERA) |
| Day 42 |
| ARKANSAS GATORS20-19 A. Joss, R (3-5, 5.03 ERA) | | | Texas Outlaws20-19 G. Maddux, R (3-4, 4.13 ERA) |
| Charlotte Spiders23-16 G. Cole, R (2-4, 4.43 ERA) | | | San Diego Sharks23-16 D. White, L (4-2, 2.17 ERA) |
| St. Brendan's Blue Jays23-16 C. Kluber, R (4-1, 4.37 ERA) | | | Chicago Reapers18-21 B. Adams, R (1-2, 7.07 ERA) |
| Newark Eagles22-17 E. Walsh, R (6-2, 3.18 ERA) | | | Phoenix Dragons20-19 B. Snell, L (5-1, 4.70 ERA) |
| Kentucky Horses16-23 R. Nelson, R (1-5, 7.65 ERA) | | | Homestead Grays19-20 M. Scott, R (3-3, 4.72 ERA) |
| Toledo Blue Stockings15-24 J. Arrieta, R (2-4, 5.57 ERA) | | | Reno Buffalo15-24 J. Richard, R (5-3, 4.38 ERA) |