| Day 21 |
| Chicago Suns13-7 L. Castillo, R (1-2, 5.48 ERA) | | | Barboursville Bungholes11-9 C. Kluber, R (2-1, 3.16 ERA) |
| Florida Crabs10-10 C. Sale, L (2-1, 4.44 ERA) | | | San Antonio Rock Hounds9-11 C. Kershaw, L (3-1, 4.15 ERA) |
| 2016 WS CHAMPS7-13 J. Paxton, L (0-2, 5.57 ERA) | | | Michigan Knights13-7 S. Strasburg, R (2-2, 3.08 ERA) |
| Utah Nightmares9-11 L. Severino, R (1-2, 5.54 ERA) | | | New Jersey Devils8-12 R. Hill, L (1-1, 3.22 ERA) |
| Iowa Pigs8-12 A. Wood, L (0-3, 11.66 ERA) | | | Nevada Snakes13-7 R. Ray, L (1-1, 5.68 ERA) |
| Freehold Yankees9-11 M. Scherzer, R (2-2, 3.70 ERA) | | | Lafayette Blue Jays10-10 Z. Greinke, R (2-1, 3.91 ERA) |
| Day 22 |
| San Antonio Rock Hounds9-11 D. Keuchel, L (2-2, 4.10 ERA) | | | Freehold Yankees9-11 J. Verlander, R (1-0, 2.31 ERA) |
| Lafayette Blue Jays10-10 C. Carrasco, R (0-1, 5.68 ERA) | | | Michigan Knights13-7 G. Gonzalez, L (0-1, 2.73 ERA) |
| Chicago Suns13-7 C. Anderson, R (0-1, 5.96 ERA) | | | Florida Crabs10-10 Y. Darvish, R (1-1, 4.97 ERA) |
| Barboursville Bungholes11-9 Z. Godley, R (0-2, 5.55 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares9-11 K. Maeda, R (1-1, 3.54 ERA) |
| New Jersey Devils8-12 M. Clevinger, R (1-0, 2.61 ERA) | | | Iowa Pigs8-12 J. Samardzija, R (1-1, 4.13 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes13-7 N. Karns, R (0-0, 5.50 ERA) | | | 2016 WS CHAMPS7-13 M. Stroman, R (1-1, 4.94 ERA) |
| Day 23 |
| San Antonio Rock Hounds9-11 N. Syndergaard, R (0-2, 4.96 ERA) | | | Freehold Yankees9-11 D. Price, L (1-2, 3.43 ERA) |
| Lafayette Blue Jays10-10 D. Lamet, R (0-2, 8.00 ERA) | | | Michigan Knights13-7 E. Santana, R (4-0, 2.16 ERA) |
| Chicago Suns13-7 K. Hendricks, R (2-0, 4.01 ERA) | | | Florida Crabs10-10 J. Odorizzi, R (1-2, 3.91 ERA) |
| Barboursville Bungholes11-9 C. Morton, R (2-0, 3.24 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares9-11 M. Fulmer, R (1-2, 5.06 ERA) |
| New Jersey Devils8-12 A. Miranda, L (1-2, 4.84 ERA) | | | Iowa Pigs8-12 C. Sabathia, L (1-1, 5.59 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes13-7 A. Cobb, R (1-2, 3.18 ERA) | | | 2016 WS CHAMPS7-13 B. Peacock, R (0-2, 5.28 ERA) |