| Day 123 |
| Cincinnati Reds52-70 B. Mathews, R (9-20, 4.46 ERA) | | | New York Giants54-68 E. Cushman, L (5-15, 4.35 ERA) |
| St Louis Cardinals58-64 P. Galvin, R (19-14, 4.73 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs66-56 C. Radbourn, R (18-11, 3.91 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates65-57 E. Morris, L (22-14, 4.28 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies63-59 M. Kilroy, L (19-11, 4.49 ERA) |
| Louisville Colonels70-52 G. Hecker, R (19-15, 3.20 ERA) | | | Boston Braves60-62 H. Porter, R (10-15, 4.96 ERA) |
| Day 124 |
| Chicago Cubs66-56 J. Cattanach, R (20-9, 3.81 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Pirates65-57 L. Baldwin, L (14-21, 3.80 ERA) |
| Boston Braves60-62 J. Whitney, R (18-11, 3.71 ERA) | | | St Louis Cardinals58-64 B. Caruthers, R (9-15, 4.72 ERA) |
| New York Giants54-68 T. Keefe, R (13-21, 4.01 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies63-59 C. Ferguson, R (12-25, 4.63 ERA) |
| Louisville Colonels70-52 T. Ramsey, L (21-12, 3.83 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds52-70 B. Taylor, R (15-16, 4.29 ERA) |
| Day 125 |
| Chicago Cubs66-56 C. Sweeney, R (13-18, 4.09 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Pirates65-57 C. Getzein, R (17-19, 4.51 ERA) |
| Boston Braves60-62 C. Buffinton, R (12-23, 4.49 ERA) | | | St Louis Cardinals58-64 D. Foutz, R (18-14, 4.25 ERA) |
| New York Giants54-68 M. Welch, R (22-14, 3.77 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies63-59 H. Henderson, R (17-18, 4.53 ERA) |
| Louisville Colonels70-52 C. Sweeney, R (17-14, 3.75 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds52-70 R. Deagle, R (2-1, 3.76 ERA) |