| Day 62 |
| Carolina Bulldogs25-36 R. Halladay, R (5-5, 4.98 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox34-27 J. Vazquez, R (5-0, 5.26 ERA) |
| New Jersey Devils28-33 A. Pettitte, L (3-7, 5.86 ERA) | | | Sacramento Lions34-27 O. Perez, L (5-2, 4.16 ERA) |
| NL 2005 All Stars26-35 R. Oswalt, R (2-4, 5.92 ERA) | | | Little Rock Tigers34-27 J. Weaver, R (2-3, 4.80 ERA) |
| Burnham Old Sluggers29-32 M. Mussina, R (4-5, 5.40 ERA) | | | Boulder Cavemen29-32 O. Perez, L (3-4, 6.10 ERA) |
| Boston Bees35-26 T. Wakefield, R (0-2, 3.49 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs31-30 D. Haren, R (5-7, 5.71 ERA) |
| Florida Crabs32-29 Z. Greinke, R (7-2, 4.91 ERA) | | | Portland Vikings29-32 A. Burnett, R (3-5, 3.72 ERA) |
| Day 63 |
| Carolina Bulldogs25-36 C. Zambrano, R (2-8, 6.75 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox34-27 J. Duchscherer, R (6-3, 4.16 ERA) |
| New Jersey Devils28-33 R. Nolasco, R (1-8, 7.98 ERA) | | | Sacramento Lions34-27 C. Sabathia, L (6-7, 5.35 ERA) |
| NL 2005 All Stars26-35 J. Peavy, R (5-6, 5.26 ERA) | | | Little Rock Tigers34-27 C. Young, R (6-3, 4.04 ERA) |
| Burnham Old Sluggers29-32 T. Hudson, R (6-6, 4.80 ERA) | | | Boulder Cavemen29-32 M. Buehrle, L (2-5, 6.61 ERA) |
| Boston Bees35-26 W. Williams, R (5-6, 4.79 ERA) | | | Minnesota Frogs31-30 W. Alvarez, L (0-3, 4.67 ERA) |
| Florida Crabs32-29 M. Prior, R (6-4, 3.83 ERA) | | | Portland Vikings29-32 T. Lilly, L (4-4, 3.74 ERA) |
| Day 64 |
| Sacramento Lions34-27 J. Johnson, R (5-4, 4.77 ERA) | | | NL 2005 All Stars26-35 D. Willis, L (4-2, 3.81 ERA) |
| Portland Vikings29-32 B. Sheets, R (2-4, 4.55 ERA) | | | Burnham Old Sluggers29-32 D. Lowe, R (4-3, 4.46 ERA) |
| Florida Crabs32-29 C. Carpenter, R (6-5, 4.54 ERA) | | | Boston Bees35-26 K. Wood, R (9-3, 3.36 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox34-27 E. Bedard, L (1-7, 5.92 ERA) | | | Little Rock Tigers34-27 J. Maine, R (5-2, 4.50 ERA) |
| Boulder Cavemen29-32 K. Millwood, R (4-4, 5.66 ERA) | | | New Jersey Devils28-33 C. Lee, L (3-6, 4.96 ERA) |
| Minnesota Frogs31-30 J. Moyer, L (2-4, 5.08 ERA) | | | Carolina Bulldogs25-36 M. Clement, R (2-7, 8.16 ERA) |