| Day 51 |
| Audrey’s Lions29-21 M. Scherzer, R (2-2, 3.82 ERA) | | | Hamilton Tiger Cat's26-24 J. Verlander, R (4-3, 4.13 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Plunder28-22 G. Cole, R (6-3, 2.53 ERA) | | | Ashtabula Ants25-25 C. Kershaw, L (3-2, 3.19 ERA) |
| Texas Outlaws20-30 J. Arrieta, R (1-7, 5.84 ERA) | | | California SHEEP27-23 C. Sale, L (1-3, 3.86 ERA) |
| Flying Brawlers25-25 J. deGrom, R (3-4, 3.48 ERA) | | | Seattle Sloths24-26 C. Kluber, R (2-4, 3.70 ERA) |
| Minnesota Frogs23-27 J. Flaherty, R (4-4, 3.96 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares27-23 Z. Greinke, R (5-2, 2.95 ERA) |
| Las Vegas Gladiators21-29 B. Snell, L (3-2, 3.52 ERA) | | | Rochester Roughnecks25-25 J. Cueto, R (4-3, 4.21 ERA) |
| Day 52 |
| California SHEEP27-23 R. Oswalt, R (4-3, 4.48 ERA) | | | Audrey’s Lions29-21 A. Nola, R (5-1, 3.94 ERA) |
| Hamilton Tiger Cat's26-24 R. Hill, L (3-3, 4.78 ERA) | | | Ashtabula Ants25-25 S. Strasburg, R (3-5, 6.23 ERA) |
| Utah Nightmares27-23 G. Richards, R (3-3, 5.18 ERA) | | | Flying Brawlers25-25 D. Hudson, R (3-3, 5.84 ERA) |
| Rochester Roughnecks25-25 M. Bumgarner, L (2-8, 6.04 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder28-22 M. Harvey, R (6-3, 3.48 ERA) |
| Minnesota Frogs23-27 J. Fernandez, R (4-4, 3.44 ERA) | | | Texas Outlaws20-30 Y. Darvish, R (5-3, 3.23 ERA) |
| Seattle Sloths24-26 C. Carrasco, R (0-1, 5.40 ERA) | | | Las Vegas Gladiators21-29 L. Severino, R (0-3, 5.76 ERA) |
| Day 53 |
| California SHEEP27-23 J. Shields, R (2-5, 5.68 ERA) | | | Audrey’s Lions29-21 J. Beckett, R (4-1, 5.56 ERA) |
| Hamilton Tiger Cat's26-24 W. Buehler, R (6-2, 4.37 ERA) | | | Ashtabula Ants25-25 D. Price, L (4-2, 5.14 ERA) |
| Utah Nightmares27-23 H. Iwakuma, R (3-4, 3.82 ERA) | | | Flying Brawlers25-25 M. Clevinger, R (2-2, 3.09 ERA) |
| Rochester Roughnecks25-25 K. Hendricks, R (3-6, 4.24 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder28-22 M. Tanaka, R (5-2, 4.66 ERA) |
| Minnesota Frogs23-27 J. Weaver, R (3-5, 5.40 ERA) | | | Texas Outlaws20-30 K. Maeda, R (1-2, 4.03 ERA) |
| Seattle Sloths24-26 C. Buchholz, R (2-6, 4.54 ERA) | | | Las Vegas Gladiators21-29 N. Syndergaard, R (4-4, 5.50 ERA) |