| Day 11 |
| Omaha Owls6-4 H. Krause, L (1-1, 1.88 ERA) | | | Homestead Grays5-5 P. Alexander, R (1-1, 1.62 ERA) |
| Cleveland Spiders4-6 W. Johnson, R (0-2, 4.80 ERA) | | | Jersey HENCHMEN6-4 D. Leonard, L (2-0, 0.00 ERA) |
| Utah Nightmares6-4 C. Bender, R (1-1, 4.05 ERA) | | | Montana Ducks5-5 F. Schupp, L (0-2, 5.73 ERA) |
| Phoenix Dragons5-5 B. Adams, R (2-0, 2.31 ERA) | | | Arizona Suns6-4 R. Ford, R (1-1, 3.18 ERA) |
| Atlanta Privateers3-7 C. Mathewson, R (0-1, 0.64 ERA) | | | New Jersey Devils5-5 J. Pfiester, L (1-1, 4.38 ERA) |
| Malevolent Nine5-5 E. Walsh, R (1-1, 4.82 ERA) | | | Toronto Tigers4-6 G. Hecker, R (2-0, 1.56 ERA) |
| Day 12 |
| Omaha Owls6-4 T. Keefe, R (0-1, 12.86 ERA) | | | Homestead Grays5-5 D. White, L (0-2, 9.00 ERA) |
| Cleveland Spiders4-6 E. Cicotte, R (0-2, 9.28 ERA) | | | Jersey HENCHMEN6-4 H. Boyle, R (1-1, 4.73 ERA) |
| Utah Nightmares6-4 M. Brown, R (2-0, 4.91 ERA) | | | Montana Ducks5-5 E. Morris, L (2-0, 3.38 ERA) |
| Phoenix Dragons5-5 A. Joss, R (2-0, 2.20 ERA) | | | Arizona Suns6-4 C. Sweeney, R (1-1, 2.76 ERA) |
| Atlanta Privateers3-7 L. Baldwin, L (0-1, 3.60 ERA) | | | New Jersey Devils5-5 S. King, R (1-1, 6.17 ERA) |
| Malevolent Nine5-5 J. Lynch, R (1-0, 4.50 ERA) | | | Toronto Tigers4-6 R. Waddell, L (0-2, 5.40 ERA) |
| Day 13 |
| Arizona Suns6-4 S. Coveleski, R (0-1, 8.49 ERA) | | | Cleveland Spiders4-6 E. Reulbach, R (0-0, 16.71 ERA) |
| Atlanta Privateers3-7 L. Corcoran, R (2-0, 1.88 ERA) | | | Malevolent Nine5-5 C. Hendrix, R (0-2, 8.22 ERA) |
| Homestead Grays5-5 B. Pelty, R (1-0, 5.65 ERA) | | | Jersey HENCHMEN6-4 C. Young, R (1-1, 1.59 ERA) |
| Montana Ducks5-5 T. Hughes, R (0-1, 4.66 ERA) | | | Phoenix Dragons5-5 B. Shawkey, R (0-1, 3.97 ERA) |
| New Jersey Devils5-5 G. McConnell, R (1-1, 4.22 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares6-4 J. Powell, R (1-0, 8.53 ERA) |
| Toronto Tigers4-6 E. Plank, L (0-1, 9.58 ERA) | | | Omaha Owls6-4 C. Radbourn, R (2-0, 2.00 ERA) |