| Day 36 |
| CIN Gators6-29 H. McCormick, R (1-4, 4.83 ERA) | | | NY Sloth23-12 B. Bruney, R (0-3, 5.84 ERA) |
| Cleveland Caterers18-17 S. Siebert, R (3-2, 5.82 ERA) | | | ARI Suns17-18 R. Nelson, R (2-2, 3.97 ERA) |
| Detroit Tigers19-16 T. Skubal, L (3-2, 2.42 ERA) | | | KC Royals18-17 S. Busby, R (0-0, 2.04 ERA) |
| LAD Devils16-19 R. Martinez, R (3-3, 4.37 ERA) | | | Colorado Rockies25-10 U. Jimenez, R (3-1, 3.07 ERA) |
| CUBS LEGENDS18-17 J. Pfiester, L (0-5, 10.73 ERA) | | | Texas Rangers18-17 N. Eovaldi, R (2-2, 4.30 ERA) |
| Elgin Longhorns22-13 G. Cole, R (0-4, 8.06 ERA) | | | ATL Horses10-25 K. Wright, R (2-5, 10.41 ERA) |
| Day 37 |
| ATL Horses10-25 I. Young, L (3-4, 4.10 ERA) | | | Detroit Tigers19-16 J. Verlander, R (2-3, 3.74 ERA) |
| Cleveland Caterers18-17 F. Beebe, R (1-2, 5.67 ERA) | | | CUBS LEGENDS18-17 C. Lundgren, R (3-2, 2.28 ERA) |
| Colorado Rockies25-10 J. Chacin, R (4-0, 3.26 ERA) | | | Elgin Longhorns22-13 M. Scott, R (6-0, 2.82 ERA) |
| NY Sloth23-12 G. Cole, R (0-1, 7.30 ERA) | | | KC Royals18-17 B. Saberhagen, R (3-4, 4.98 ERA) |
| ARI Suns17-18 C. Buchholz, R (4-2, 2.34 ERA) | | | LAD Devils16-19 J. Cronin, R (0-4, 6.46 ERA) |
| Texas Rangers18-17 N. Ryan, R (3-3, 5.48 ERA) | | | CIN Gators6-29 J. Cueto, R (0-5, 6.35 ERA) |
| Day 38 |
| ATL Horses10-25 T. Glavine, L (2-4, 4.38 ERA) | | | Detroit Tigers19-16 M. Scherzer, R (2-4, 5.48 ERA) |
| Cleveland Caterers18-17 T. Candiotti, R (4-2, 4.53 ERA) | | | CUBS LEGENDS18-17 R. Harden, R (0-1, 4.41 ERA) |
| Colorado Rockies25-10 J. De La Rosa, L (4-0, 3.18 ERA) | | | Elgin Longhorns22-13 C. Javier, R (3-0, 2.57 ERA) |
| NY Sloth23-12 L. Severino, R (2-2, 4.46 ERA) | | | KC Royals18-17 D. Rasmussen, L (0-2, 4.34 ERA) |
| ARI Suns17-18 M. Kelly, R (2-4, 7.58 ERA) | | | LAD Devils16-19 O. Perez, L (4-3, 5.82 ERA) |
| Texas Rangers18-17 J. deGrom, R (0-3, 8.59 ERA) | | | CIN Gators6-29 E. Blackwell, R (1-5, 5.08 ERA) |