| Day 1 |
| 1956 Cleveland Indians0-0 H. Moford, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 New York Giants0-0 J. Harshman, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1951 Cleveland Indians0-0 J. Jay, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1956 Cincinnati Redlegs0-0 W. Spahn, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1961 New York Yankees0-0 J. Bunning, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1958 San Francisco Giants0-0 B. Pierce, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1959 New York Yankees0-0 S. Miller, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1959 Milwaukee Braves0-0 P. Foytack, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1952 Philadelphia A's0-0 G. Bell, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 Boston Red Sox0-0 S. Jones, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1950 Boston Red Sox0-0 D. Cardwell, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 Boston Red Sox0-0 S. Koufax, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1958 Chicago White Sox0-0 A. Portocarrero, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1957 St. Louis Cardinals0-0 C. Willey, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1952 Philadelphia Phillies0-0 J. Pizarro, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1954 Brooklyn Dodgers0-0 B. O'Dell, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1951 Chicago White Sox0-0 B. Turley, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1951 St. Louis Cardinals0-0 G. Witt, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1955 Boston Red Sox0-0 H. Wilhelm, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1952 Chicago Cubs0-0 B. Latman, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1958 Pittsburgh Pirates0-0 J. Buzhardt, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 Brooklyn Dodgers0-0 W. Ford, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| 1956 Cleveland Indians0-0 R. Roberts, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 New York Giants0-0 F. Lary, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1951 Cleveland Indians0-0 L. Burdette, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1956 Cincinnati Redlegs0-0 J. Antonelli, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1961 New York Yankees0-0 D. Donovan, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1958 San Francisco Giants0-0 H. Brown, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1959 New York Yankees0-0 C. Johnson, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1959 Milwaukee Braves0-0 B. Rush, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1952 Philadelphia A's0-0 A. Kellner, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 Boston Red Sox0-0 M. Pappas, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1958 Chicago White Sox0-0 D. Maas, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1957 St. Louis Cardinals0-0 E. Wynn, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1952 Philadelphia Phillies0-0 R. Herbert, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1954 Brooklyn Dodgers0-0 C. Pascual, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1951 Chicago White Sox0-0 R. Moore, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1951 St. Louis Cardinals0-0 A. Ditmar, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1955 Boston Red Sox0-0 D. Larsen, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1952 Chicago Cubs0-0 R. Craig, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1958 Pittsburgh Pirates0-0 C. McLish, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 Brooklyn Dodgers0-0 C. Raydon, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 3 |
| 1956 Cleveland Indians0-0 J. Nuxhall, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 New York Giants0-0 B. Monbouquette, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1951 Cleveland Indians0-0 N. Garver, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1956 Cincinnati Redlegs0-0 J. Podres, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1961 New York Yankees0-0 J. Brosnan, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1958 San Francisco Giants0-0 R. Terry, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1959 New York Yankees0-0 H. Haddix, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1959 Milwaukee Braves0-0 D. Hillman, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1952 Philadelphia A's0-0 B. Loes, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 Boston Red Sox0-0 D. Sisler, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1958 Chicago White Sox0-0 B. Anderson, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1957 St. Louis Cardinals0-0 B. Purkey, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1952 Philadelphia Phillies0-0 M. Dickson, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1954 Brooklyn Dodgers0-0 I. Delock, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1951 Chicago White Sox0-0 H. Score, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1951 St. Louis Cardinals0-0 D. Drysdale, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1955 Boston Red Sox0-0 R. Kline, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1952 Chicago Cubs0-0 S. Williams, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| 1958 Pittsburgh Pirates0-0 M. Grant, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | 1950 Brooklyn Dodgers0-0 B. Shantz, L (0-0, - ERA) |