| Day 1 |
| Upper West Side Mets65-45 R. Clemens, R (14-7, 2.86 ERA) | | | Long Island City Stars50-56 J. Abbott, L (11-8, 3.43 ERA) |
| Corona Black Katz68-42 B. McDonald, R (7-13, 4.42 ERA) | | | Hell's Kitchen Junkies44-62 J. Bunning, R (5-11, 3.90 ERA) |
| Astoria Renegades49-57 C. Schilling, R (8-7, 3.28 ERA) | | | Riverdale Jaspers62-59 T. Wilson, L (2-4, 3.55 ERA) |
| Oakwood Heights Jokers59-52 S. Militello, R (9-7, 3.67 ERA) | | | Red Hook Kodiaks34-72 D. Sutton, R (7-10, 3.87 ERA) |
| Morningside Heights Street Meat65-52 A. Rhodes, L (12-9, 4.13 ERA) | | | Howard Beach Firebirds47-59 A. Benes, R (4-18, 5.64 ERA) |
| Sunset Park Stallions68-47 G. Harris, R (14-8, 3.17 ERA) | | | Arden Heights PodFathers🇺🇦52-54 W. Ford, L (7-14, 4.66 ERA) |
| St. George Yankees61-48 C. Hunter, R (13-7, 3.08 ERA) | | | Bensonhurst Sweathogs48-58 S. Carlton, L (10-9, 3.69 ERA) |
| Coney Island Cyclones71-46 T. Candiotti, R (7-7, 4.24 ERA) | | | Port Richmond Wiseguys36-70 D. Cone, R (7-9, 6.24 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Upper West Side Mets65-45 K. Hill, R (10-8, 3.42 ERA) | | | Long Island City Stars50-56 J. Bere, R (11-7, 2.86 ERA) |
| Corona Black Katz68-42 F. Castillo, R (13-7, 4.54 ERA) | | | Hell's Kitchen Junkies44-62 J. Rijo, R (13-7, 3.49 ERA) |
| Astoria Renegades49-57 G. Maddux, R (9-11, 4.76 ERA) | | | Riverdale Jaspers62-59 M. Langston, L (11-8, 3.31 ERA) |
| Oakwood Heights Jokers59-52 S. Erickson, R (7-5, 4.07 ERA) | | | Red Hook Kodiaks34-72 P. Martinez, R (3-15, 4.01 ERA) |
| Morningside Heights Street Meat65-52 M. Gardner, R (10-10, 4.17 ERA) | | | Howard Beach Firebirds47-59 C. Eldred, R (8-10, 3.33 ERA) |
| Sunset Park Stallions68-47 J. Marichal, R (13-6, 3.57 ERA) | | | Arden Heights PodFathers🇺🇦52-54 J. Smiley, L (10-10, 4.01 ERA) |
| St. George Yankees61-48 T. Glavine, L (17-7, 3.67 ERA) | | | Bensonhurst Sweathogs48-58 T. Greene, R (9-9, 3.97 ERA) |
| Coney Island Cyclones71-46 T. Seaver, R (12-13, 3.76 ERA) | | | Port Richmond Wiseguys36-70 R. Martinez, R (5-14, 5.19 ERA) |
| Day 3 |
| Upper West Side Mets65-45 C. Nabholz, L (15-5, 3.95 ERA) | | | Long Island City Stars50-56 D. Wells, L (5-8, 5.43 ERA) |
| Corona Black Katz68-42 M. Leiter, R (3-3, 3.73 ERA) | | | Hell's Kitchen Junkies44-62 B. Saberhagen, R (6-12, 4.57 ERA) |
| Astoria Renegades49-57 J. McDowell, R (6-10, 5.06 ERA) | | | Riverdale Jaspers62-59 K. Rueter, L (8-10, 3.73 ERA) |
| Oakwood Heights Jokers59-52 T. Gordon, R (1-7, 6.84 ERA) | | | Red Hook Kodiaks34-72 R. Johnson, L (5-11, 4.37 ERA) |
| Morningside Heights Street Meat65-52 J. Guzman, R (9-11, 4.26 ERA) | | | Howard Beach Firebirds47-59 D. Drysdale, R (8-10, 4.09 ERA) |
| Sunset Park Stallions68-47 C. Bosio, R (13-4, 3.94 ERA) | | | Arden Heights PodFathers🇺🇦52-54 T. Stottlemyre, R (11-6, 4.34 ERA) |
| St. George Yankees61-48 T. Wakefield, R (6-6, 4.74 ERA) | | | Bensonhurst Sweathogs48-58 S. Avery, L (6-9, 3.73 ERA) |
| Coney Island Cyclones71-46 J. Guzman, R (13-7, 3.23 ERA) | | | Port Richmond Wiseguys36-70 S. Reynolds, R (6-8, 4.67 ERA) |