| Day 1 |
| Pittsburgh 1980-1999 Generation X0-0 R. Rhoden, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1880-1899 Pirates0-0 F. Sullivan, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Pittsburgh 1960-1979 Glory Years0-0 J. Reuss, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1900-1919 Dead Ball0-0 B. Adams, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Pittsburgh 2000-2019 Millenials0-0 J. Musgrove, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1920-1939 Ruthian Ear0-0 C. Hill, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Pittsburgh 1960-1979 Glory Years0-0 B. Blyleven, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1900-1919 Dead Ball0-0 W. Cooper, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Pittsburgh 2000-2019 Millenials0-0 F. Liriano, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1920-1939 Ruthian Ear0-0 W. Hoyt, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Pittsburgh 1880-1899 Pirates0-0 H. Staley, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1980-1999 Generation X0-0 J. Smiley, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 3 |
| Pittsburgh 1960-1979 Glory Years0-0 D. Ellis, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1900-1919 Dead Ball0-0 L. Leifield, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Pittsburgh 1880-1899 Pirates0-0 E. Morris, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1980-1999 Generation X0-0 F. Cordova, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Pittsburgh 1920-1939 Ruthian Ear0-0 B. Klinger, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 2000-2019 Millenials0-0 G. Cole, R (0-0, - ERA) |