| Day 43 |
| ddddd ddddd19-23 K. Hendricks, R (2-4, 7.89 ERA) | | | Team 6 Team 620-22 V. Blue, L (3-2, 5.20 ERA) |
| fffff ffffff22-20 T. Higuera, L (3-3, 5.50 ERA) | | | Team 4 Team 419-23 J. Flaherty, R (2-3, 3.38 ERA) |
| bbbb bbbbb19-23 D. Wilson, R (3-3, 4.45 ERA) | | | aaaa aaaaa21-21 M. Harvey, R (2-4, 5.68 ERA) |
| cccc ccccc24-18 C. Bender, R (3-3, 8.44 ERA) | | | Team 7 Team 719-23 T. Seaver, R (4-3, 5.04 ERA) |
| Team 1 Team 125-17 F. Hernandez, R (1-2, 6.75 ERA) | | | Brian Sytsma23-19 F. Tanana, L (3-3, 6.44 ERA) |
| hhhhh hhhhh24-18 C. Mathewson, R (4-3, 4.80 ERA) | | | Team 2 Team 224-18 B. Snell, L (2-3, 4.50 ERA) |
| eeeee eeeeee20-22 C. Hunter, R (2-4, 7.06 ERA) | | | Team 5 Team 514-28 J. deGrom, R (2-2, 1.95 ERA) |
| ggggg gggggg26-16 D. Gooden, R (5-3, 4.67 ERA) | | | Team 3 Team 317-25 D. Sutton, R (4-3, 6.17 ERA) |
| Day 44 |
| ddddd ddddd19-23 B. Pelty, R (5-3, 4.40 ERA) | | | Team 6 Team 620-22 S. Siebert, R (1-3, 6.75 ERA) |
| fffff ffffff22-20 F. Smith, R (3-3, 5.96 ERA) | | | Team 4 Team 419-23 D. Hughes, R (2-4, 4.53 ERA) |
| bbbb bbbbb19-23 B. Saberhagen, R (2-4, 6.55 ERA) | | | aaaa aaaaa21-21 D. White, L (2-3, 7.24 ERA) |
| cccc ccccc24-18 M. Cuellar, L (3-2, 9.06 ERA) | | | Team 7 Team 719-23 J. Pfiester, L (2-5, 5.03 ERA) |
| Team 1 Team 125-17 M. Brown, R (6-1, 4.66 ERA) | | | Brian Sytsma23-19 K. Millwood, R (4-2, 4.13 ERA) |
| hhhhh hhhhh24-18 G. Perry, R (4-4, 3.31 ERA) | | | Team 2 Team 224-18 R. Johnson, L (5-3, 4.29 ERA) |
| eeeee eeeeee20-22 D. Chance, R (3-3, 4.96 ERA) | | | Team 5 Team 514-28 M. Cooper, R (1-5, 8.72 ERA) |
| ggggg gggggg26-16 J. Coombs, R (6-1, 4.57 ERA) | | | Team 3 Team 317-25 H. Krause, L (3-3, 5.26 ERA) |
| Day 45 |
| ddddd ddddd19-23 C. Hamels, L (3-2, 5.84 ERA) | | | Team 6 Team 620-22 E. Cicotte, R (3-4, 7.36 ERA) |
| fffff ffffff22-20 J. McGinnity, R (4-4, 5.32 ERA) | | | Team 4 Team 419-23 T. Hughes, R (1-5, 6.99 ERA) |
| bbbb bbbbb19-23 M. Scherzer, R (4-1, 3.00 ERA) | | | aaaa aaaaa21-21 J. Chesbro, R (4-3, 4.95 ERA) |
| cccc ccccc24-18 J. DeLeon, R (3-4, 6.89 ERA) | | | Team 7 Team 719-23 S. Carlton, L (1-5, 7.29 ERA) |
| Team 1 Team 125-17 C. Schilling, R (4-2, 5.65 ERA) | | | Brian Sytsma23-19 D. Lowe, R (2-4, 3.72 ERA) |
| hhhhh hhhhh24-18 D. Drysdale, R (3-3, 5.32 ERA) | | | Team 2 Team 224-18 J. Tudor, L (4-4, 6.18 ERA) |
| eeeee eeeeee20-22 S. Coveleski, R (3-2, 5.92 ERA) | | | Team 5 Team 514-28 H. Nomo, R (2-6, 8.58 ERA) |
| ggggg gggggg26-16 J. Lester, L (4-4, 5.26 ERA) | | | Team 3 Team 317-25 L. Tiant, R (3-5, 4.76 ERA) |