| Day 1 |
| New York 1980s Yankees70-92 R. May, L (3-10, 4.14 ERA) | | | New York 1950s Yankees78-84 B. Turley, R (9-9, 4.02 ERA) |
| New York 2010s Yankees90-72 M. Tanaka, R (9-15, 5.33 ERA) | | | New York 1920s Yankees83-79 R. Collins, R (7-8, 4.41 ERA) |
| Atlanta 1990s Braves89-73 G. Maddux, R (10-8, 4.33 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1900s Pirates66-96 H. Camnitz, R (11-13, 3.36 ERA) |
| Baltimore 1960s Orioles66-96 D. McNally, L (8-23, 7.04 ERA) | | | St. Louis 1940s Cardinals103-59 M. Cooper, R (14-13, 3.92 ERA) |
| New York 2000s Yankees77-85 T. Lilly, L (1-10, 6.11 ERA) | | | New York 1930s Yankees88-74 O. Hildebrand, R (12-11, 5.65 ERA) |
| Cincinnati 1970 Reds89-73 W. Simpson, R (17-11, 3.57 ERA) | | | New York 1910s Giants73-89 B. Steele, L (6-12, 5.04 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| New York 1980s Yankees70-92 C. Cary, L (6-13, 4.78 ERA) | | | New York 1950s Yankees78-84 V. Raschi, R (15-13, 4.80 ERA) |
| New York 2010s Yankees90-72 J. Happ, L (12-15, 4.83 ERA) | | | New York 1920s Yankees83-79 J. Bush, R (13-11, 5.15 ERA) |
| Atlanta 1990s Braves89-73 D. Nied, R (5-8, 2.95 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh 1900s Pirates66-96 V. Willis, R (7-14, 5.63 ERA) |
| Baltimore 1960s Orioles66-96 M. Cuellar, L (9-22, 6.64 ERA) | | | St. Louis 1940s Cardinals103-59 H. Brecheen, L (11-11, 4.68 ERA) |
| New York 2000s Yankees77-85 C. Sabathia, L (14-12, 5.22 ERA) | | | New York 1930s Yankees88-74 R. Ruffing, R (14-9, 5.05 ERA) |
| Cincinnati 1970 Reds89-73 D. Gullett, L (11-10, 4.64 ERA) | | | New York 1910s Giants73-89 J. Tesreau, R (13-10, 3.30 ERA) |