| Day 95 |
| Boulder Cavemen45-49 H. Ryu, L (5-7, 4.24 ERA) | | | Iowa Corn Pickers47-47 M. Foltynewicz, R (6-9, 4.25 ERA) |
| Venice Beach Hulkamaniacs58-36 T. Bauer, R (10-4, 4.17 ERA) | | | Jersey City Scooters58-36 S. Gray, R (5-4, 4.12 ERA) |
| Florida Crabs49-45 H. Iwakuma, R (6-8, 6.51 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders39-55 P. Corbin, L (5-10, 5.32 ERA) |
| 3rd Party Candidates50-44 L. Giolito, R (4-7, 4.71 ERA) | | | Nevada Snakes50-44 A. Wood, L (5-10, 6.36 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns43-51 D. Haren, R (7-4, 5.35 ERA) | | | Toronto Tigers47-47 R. Halladay, R (9-6, 4.05 ERA) |
| Montana Ducks35-59 J. Johnson, R (6-9, 5.03 ERA) | | | Saratoga Stallions43-51 J. Weaver, R (6-9, 6.26 ERA) |
| Day 96 |
| Boulder Cavemen45-49 M. Latos, R (8-4, 3.49 ERA) | | | Iowa Corn Pickers47-47 J. Lackey, R (7-8, 6.32 ERA) |
| Venice Beach Hulkamaniacs58-36 J. Beckett, R (3-6, 4.53 ERA) | | | Jersey City Scooters58-36 Y. Darvish, R (8-4, 3.31 ERA) |
| Florida Crabs49-45 G. Gonzalez, L (5-8, 6.77 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders39-55 J. Shields, R (6-6, 6.05 ERA) |
| 3rd Party Candidates50-44 R. Oswalt, R (6-6, 5.11 ERA) | | | Nevada Snakes50-44 S. Bieber, R (6-9, 6.46 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns43-51 J. Paxton, L (5-8, 6.15 ERA) | | | Toronto Tigers47-47 A. Griffin, R (6-7, 4.59 ERA) |
| Montana Ducks35-59 F. Liriano, L (6-8, 5.05 ERA) | | | Saratoga Stallions43-51 R. Porcello, R (7-8, 5.23 ERA) |
| Day 97 |
| Toronto Tigers47-47 M. Tanaka, R (8-9, 5.04 ERA) | | | Iowa Corn Pickers47-47 K. Hendricks, R (8-7, 5.84 ERA) |
| Jersey City Scooters58-36 C. Sale, L (10-5, 3.98 ERA) | | | 3rd Party Candidates50-44 J. Verlander, R (10-7, 4.18 ERA) |
| Saratoga Stallions43-51 C. Hamels, L (6-12, 4.54 ERA) | | | Venice Beach Hulkamaniacs58-36 C. Kershaw, L (9-5, 4.19 ERA) |
| Charlotte Spiders39-55 M. Harvey, R (6-9, 4.86 ERA) | | | Arizona Suns43-51 C. Buchholz, R (6-9, 5.79 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes50-44 J. Cueto, R (13-2, 3.65 ERA) | | | Boulder Cavemen45-49 J. Lester, L (5-11, 4.14 ERA) |
| Montana Ducks35-59 C. Lee, L (5-8, 7.83 ERA) | | | Florida Crabs49-45 F. Hernandez, R (8-5, 4.40 ERA) |