| Day 1 |
| 1968 Tigers28-28 J. Hiller, L (0-1, 2.45 ERA) | | | 1929 Athletics25-31 L. Grove, L (3-3, 4.96 ERA) |
| 1984 Tigers30-27 D. Petry, R (2-6, 6.10 ERA) | | | 1967 Cardinals20-37 B. Gibson, R (5-5, 3.48 ERA) |
| 1961 Yankees31-25 W. Ford, L (4-3, 2.94 ERA) | | | 1969 Mets29-27 J. Koosman, L (6-3, 1.66 ERA) |
| 1978 MystiqueAura31-25 C. Hunter, R (6-4, 2.30 ERA) | | | 1970 Orioles28-28 M. Cuellar, L (3-7, 4.15 ERA) |
| 1995 Braves26-30 J. Smoltz, R (2-5, 3.59 ERA) | | | 1975 Reds23-33 G. Nolan, R (2-4, 2.81 ERA) |
| 1989 Athletics24-32 B. Welch, R (1-8, 5.90 ERA) | | | 1976 Reds30-26 G. Nolan, R (8-3, 2.35 ERA) |
| 1972 A's26-30 B. Odom, R (2-7, 3.96 ERA) | | | 1998 Yankees31-25 O. Hernandez, R (6-3, 2.04 ERA) |
| 1986 Mets31-25 B. Ojeda, L (4-0, 1.66 ERA) | | | 2018 Red Sox37-19 D. Price, L (5-3, 3.57 ERA) |
| 1979 Pirates21-35 B. Kison, R (2-4, 4.37 ERA) | | | 2016 Cubs36-20 J. Lester, L (5-6, 2.34 ERA) |
| 1993 Blue Jays22-34 P. Hentgen, R (4-6, 4.16 ERA) | | | 2004 Sox30-26 P. Martinez, R (6-4, 3.40 ERA) |
| 1927 Yanks23-33 W. Hoyt, R (3-6, 4.22 ERA) | | | 1932 Bronx Bombers23-33 R. Ruffing, R (2-7, 4.75 ERA) |
| 1939 Pinstripes37-19 O. Hildebrand, R (5-5, 3.91 ERA) | | | 2001 Diamondbacks31-25 C. Schilling, R (5-2, 2.40 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| 1969 Mets29-27 J. McAndrew, R (2-5, 2.87 ERA) | | | 1986 Mets31-25 S. Fernandez, L (3-4, 2.73 ERA) |
| 1970 Orioles28-28 J. Palmer, R (5-6, 2.51 ERA) | | | 1995 Braves26-30 T. Glavine, L (3-6, 3.86 ERA) |
| 1976 Reds30-26 F. Norman, L (7-3, 2.95 ERA) | | | 1984 Tigers30-27 M. Wilcox, R (3-2, 4.22 ERA) |
| 1929 Athletics25-31 G. Earnshaw, R (2-5, 4.57 ERA) | | | 1979 Pirates21-35 J. Candelaria, L (4-4, 3.75 ERA) |
| 1967 Cardinals20-37 S. Carlton, L (3-5, 2.59 ERA) | | | 1961 Yankees31-25 B. Stafford, R (4-2, 3.03 ERA) |
| 2016 Cubs36-20 J. Arrieta, R (5-4, 1.94 ERA) | | | 1989 Athletics24-32 D. Stewart, R (2-7, 4.23 ERA) |
| 2018 Red Sox37-19 N. Eovaldi, R (5-3, 2.78 ERA) | | | 1993 Blue Jays22-34 J. Guzman, R (4-4, 4.74 ERA) |
| 1932 Bronx Bombers23-33 L. Gomez, L (2-6, 5.91 ERA) | | | 1978 MystiqueAura31-25 E. Figueroa, R (6-3, 2.97 ERA) |
| 2001 Diamondbacks31-25 B. Anderson, L (2-3, 5.96 ERA) | | | 1972 A's26-30 C. Hunter, R (6-3, 2.45 ERA) |
| 1998 Yankees31-25 D. Cone, R (5-4, 3.97 ERA) | | | 1927 Yanks23-33 G. Pipgras, R (3-4, 5.31 ERA) |
| 1975 Reds23-33 F. Norman, L (3-3, 2.23 ERA) | | | 2004 Sox30-26 B. Arroyo, R (3-2, 3.90 ERA) |
| 1968 Tigers28-28 M. Lolich, L (3-2, 2.57 ERA) | | | 1939 Pinstripes37-19 R. Ruffing, R (8-1, 3.70 ERA) |