| Day 1 |
| City Team 1183-79 F. Montas, R (10-11, 4.94 ERA) | | | City Team 0294-68 L. Castillo, R (9-10, 4.56 ERA) |
| City Team 0763-99 H. Ryu, L (8-15, 3.55 ERA) | | | City Team 0689-73 A. Civale, R (17-8, 3.56 ERA) |
| City Team 0876-86 R. Yarbrough, L (9-9, 2.86 ERA) | | | City Team 0587-75 J. Yamamoto, R (11-7, 3.63 ERA) |
| City Team 1073-89 R. Hill, L (4-14, 5.51 ERA) | | | City Team 0371-91 Y. Chirinos, R (9-11, 3.90 ERA) |
| City Team 1295-67 D. German, R (10-8, 4.73 ERA) | | | City Team 0184-78 P. Corbin, L (7-17, 5.01 ERA) |
| City Team 0980-82 F. Pena, R (11-9, 4.02 ERA) | | | City Team 0477-85 A. Mills, R (5-9, 5.36 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| City Team 1295-67 Z. Gallen, R (15-11, 5.11 ERA) | | | City Team 1073-89 D. Lamet, R (7-16, 5.70 ERA) |
| City Team 0587-75 J. Odorizzi, R (8-12, 5.50 ERA) | | | City Team 0689-73 M. Bumgarner, L (7-9, 4.80 ERA) |
| City Team 0371-91 C. Bassitt, R (9-11, 5.64 ERA) | | | City Team 0876-86 M. Soroka, R (13-14, 4.55 ERA) |
| City Team 0477-85 M. Clevinger, R (15-11, 3.49 ERA) | | | City Team 0763-99 J. Urquidy, R (10-9, 4.12 ERA) |
| City Team 0184-78 L. Giolito, R (18-9, 3.77 ERA) | | | City Team 1183-79 C. Smith, L (12-10, 4.58 ERA) |
| City Team 0294-68 T. Milone, L (9-9, 6.40 ERA) | | | City Team 0980-82 J. Samardzija, R (7-9, 3.77 ERA) |