| Day 1 |
| Cleveland Indians86-76 B. Feller, R (10-15, 3.65 ERA) | | | Detroit Tigers73-89 H. Aguirre, L (5-10, 3.94 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates77-85 V. Law, R (12-14, 3.15 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles81-81 J. Palmer, R (15-11, 2.72 ERA) |
| Brooklyn Dodgers81-81 D. Drysdale, R (11-9, 3.70 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox89-73 E. Wilson, R (14-11, 2.85 ERA) |
| Cincinnati Redlegs94-68 B. Walters, R (17-9, 2.92 ERA) | | | New York Yankees101-61 W. Ford, L (16-10, 4.08 ERA) |
| St Louis Cardinals77-85 H. Pollet, L (12-12, 3.15 ERA) | | | New York Giants74-88 J. Hearn, R (11-9, 2.71 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox69-93 G. Peters, L (14-12, 2.82 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Braves70-92 W. Spahn, L (10-15, 3.50 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Cleveland Indians86-76 S. Siebert, R (5-5, 2.99 ERA) | | | Detroit Tigers73-89 M. Lolich, L (11-16, 4.55 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates77-85 H. Haddix, L (9-15, 3.85 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles81-81 M. Cuellar, L (14-14, 4.34 ERA) |
| Brooklyn Dodgers81-81 D. Newcombe, R (13-14, 3.71 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox89-73 T. Hughson, R (11-11, 3.38 ERA) |
| Cincinnati Redlegs94-68 J. Nuxhall, L (10-11, 3.54 ERA) | | | New York Yankees101-61 S. Bahnsen, R (16-12, 3.15 ERA) |
| St Louis Cardinals77-85 M. Cooper, R (13-13, 3.38 ERA) | | | New York Giants74-88 G. Perry, R (11-10, 3.86 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox69-93 J. Horlen, R (11-13, 3.08 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Braves70-92 C. Willey, R (16-9, 3.63 ERA) |