| Day 1 |
| New York Yankees64-98 M. Tanaka, R (14-17, 4.47 ERA) | | | San Francisco Giants95-74 C. Mathewson, R (13-19, 4.07 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Cleveland Guardians63-99 B. Feller, R (17-15, 3.40 ERA) | | | Seattle Mariners78-84 L. Gilbert, R (15-12, 3.80 ERA) |
| Washington Nationals73-89 S. Rogers, R (16-11, 3.56 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs80-82 F. Jenkins, R (11-14, 5.53 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox72-90 B. Ruth, L (8-17, 5.12 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds84-78 M. Soto, R (16-16, 5.61 ERA) |
| Detroit Tigers75-87 J. Verlander, R (19-9, 3.13 ERA) | | | San Diego Padres Legends89-75 D. Pomeranz, L (15-13, 3.95 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox95-73 J. Horlen, R (28-8, 2.79 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers109-66 F. Peralta, R (23-9, 3.69 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Angels80-85 J. Weaver, R (17-13, 4.38 ERA) | | | Houston Astros95-81 J. Urquidy, R (12-13, 5.46 ERA) |
| Minnesota Twins119-57 J. Ryan, R (20-8, 2.64 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles70-92 T. Wells, R (7-16, 4.82 ERA) |
| Texas Rangers73-89 D. Bosman, R (15-13, 2.84 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies75-87 A. Nola, R (8-15, 4.93 ERA) |
| Arizona Diamondbacks96-76 R. Ray, L (18-5, 2.21 ERA) | | | Los Angeles Dodgers79-83 C. Kershaw, L (16-15, 2.98 ERA) |
| Tampa Bay Rays102-65 B. Snell, L (18-10, 2.26 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals76-86 A. Wainwright, R (13-13, 4.09 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates65-97 J. Candelaria, L (15-13, 3.73 ERA) | | | New York Mets103-63 M. Harvey, R (21-12, 3.51 ERA) |