| Day 1 |
| New York Yankees111-68 G. Cole, R (16-15, 5.39 ERA) | | | San Francisco Giants86-79 C. Mathewson, R (10-17, 4.99 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Detroit Tigers73-89 T. Skubal, L (11-20, 5.87 ERA) | | | San Diego Padres56-106 D. Lamet, R (11-15, 3.97 ERA) |
| Texas Rangers77-85 N. Eovaldi, R (14-13, 3.55 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies120-53 R. Oswalt, R (30-5, 2.44 ERA) |
| Tampa Bay Rays80-82 D. Smyly, L (17-10, 3.48 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals93-71 B. Gibson, R (18-13, 4.96 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates83-79 P. Skenes, R (12-13, 5.20 ERA) | | | New York Mets81-81 J. deGrom, R (15-12, 3.61 ERA) |
| Washington Nationals81-81 M. Scherzer, R (13-17, 5.21 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs79-83 J. Arrieta, R (18-10, 4.67 ERA) |
| Minnesota Twins94-77 W. Johnson, R (16-15, 3.07 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles71-91 D. McNally, L (12-20, 5.42 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox89-80 P. Martinez, R (21-11, 3.10 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds80-82 T. Bauer, R (17-11, 3.72 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Angels82-82 D. Chance, R (12-15, 4.35 ERA) | | | Houston Astros83-81 J. Verlander, R (14-14, 4.31 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox69-93 J. Horlen, R (10-18, 5.62 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers89-79 M. Fiers, R (11-12, 4.05 ERA) |
| Arizona Diamondbacks71-91 Z. Gallen, R (15-12, 4.02 ERA) | | | Los Angeles Dodgers110-74 S. Koufax, L (19-12, 3.66 ERA) |
| Cleveland Indians80-82 S. Bieber, R (17-11, 3.48 ERA) | | | Seattle Mariners75-87 L. Gilbert, R (13-15, 4.78 ERA) |