| Day 31 |
| Louisville Colonels16-14 C. Sweeney, R (4-3, 3.01 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Pirates14-16 L. Baldwin, L (2-5, 5.09 ERA) |
| Chicago Cubs16-14 J. Cattanach, R (4-5, 3.80 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies13-17 H. Henderson, R (3-5, 4.70 ERA) |
| St Louis Cardinals15-15 B. Caruthers, R (1-4, 4.29 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds22-8 B. Taylor, R (7-1, 2.79 ERA) |
| New York Giants13-17 T. Keefe, R (6-4, 3.10 ERA) | | | Boston Braves11-19 J. Whitney, R (1-5, 4.46 ERA) |
| Day 32 |
| Louisville Colonels16-14 T. Ramsey, L (5-3, 2.74 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Pirates14-16 C. Getzein, R (3-6, 5.99 ERA) |
| Chicago Cubs16-14 C. Sweeney, R (4-1, 3.52 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies13-17 E. Daily, R (3-0, 2.68 ERA) |
| St Louis Cardinals15-15 D. Foutz, R (4-4, 3.73 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds22-8 B. Mountjoy, R (0-0, 2.25 ERA) |
| New York Giants13-17 M. Welch, R (4-3, 3.43 ERA) | | | Boston Braves11-19 C. Buffinton, R (3-5, 4.37 ERA) |
| Day 33 |
| Louisville Colonels16-14 G. Hecker, R (5-4, 2.91 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Pirates14-16 E. Morris, L (6-1, 4.00 ERA) |
| Chicago Cubs16-14 C. Radbourn, R (4-3, 2.74 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies13-17 C. Ferguson, R (1-2, 3.21 ERA) |
| St Louis Cardinals15-15 P. Galvin, R (5-4, 3.62 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds22-8 G. Shallix, R (6-3, 3.22 ERA) |
| New York Giants13-17 J. Lynch, R (2-6, 4.14 ERA) | | | Boston Braves11-19 H. Porter, R (1-7, 5.32 ERA) |