| Day 1 |
| Cincinnati Reds83-82 J. Cueto, R (15-12, 4.00 ERA) | | | Oakland A's87-79 R. Harden, R (15-10, 4.11 ERA) |
| Philadelphia Phillies80-82 C. Hamels, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Toronto Blue Jays67-95 R. Halladay, R (11-15, 4.72 ERA) |
| Baltimore Orioles71-91 J. Arrieta, R (13-14, 3.75 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers94-75 E. Lauer, L (10-10, 3.80 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox78-84 P. Martinez, R (9-13, 5.03 ERA) | | | Houston Astros81-82 J. Verlander, R (14-12, 3.72 ERA) |
| Cleveland Indians89-78 S. Bieber, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Tampa Bay Devil Rays96-78 C. Archer, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Cincinnati Reds83-82 T. Wood, L (14-15, 4.75 ERA) | | | Oakland A's87-79 M. Mulder, L (6-18, 5.37 ERA) |
| Philadelphia Phillies80-82 R. Wolf, L (13-10, 4.57 ERA) | | | Toronto Blue Jays67-95 O. Daal, L (5-14, 6.67 ERA) |
| Baltimore Orioles71-91 D. Bundy, R (10-18, 4.66 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers94-75 B. Woodruff, R (15-10, 3.87 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox78-84 D. Lowe, R (12-15, 4.42 ERA) | | | Houston Astros81-82 G. Cole, R (13-8, 4.41 ERA) |
| Cleveland Indians89-78 Z. Plesac, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Tampa Bay Devil Rays96-78 D. Price, L (15-16, 4.60 ERA) |