| Day 1 |
| Milwaukee Brewers83-81 F. Peralta, R (12-12, 4.16 ERA) | | | Toronto Blue Jays67-95 R. Halladay, R (4-24, 6.36 ERA) |
| Cincinnati Reds79-83 J. Cueto, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Houston Astros83-81 J. Verlander, R (13-11, 3.46 ERA) |
| Philadelphia Phillies75-87 C. Politte, R (8-12, 4.74 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles81-81 J. Arrieta, R (11-12, 3.76 ERA) |
| Oakland A's88-78 T. Lilly, L (11-10, 5.27 ERA) | | | Cleveland Indians97-75 R. Hill, L (12-10, 5.26 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox69-93 P. Martinez, R (11-13, 4.63 ERA) | | | Tampa Bay Devil Rays100-68 D. Waechter, R (17-9, 3.53 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Milwaukee Brewers83-81 B. Woodruff, R (10-14, 4.31 ERA) | | | Toronto Blue Jays67-95 O. Daal, L (9-9, 4.59 ERA) |
| Cincinnati Reds79-83 T. Wood, L (13-14, 5.03 ERA) | | | Houston Astros83-81 G. Cole, R (11-14, 3.84 ERA) |
| Philadelphia Phillies75-87 A. Telemaco, R (10-11, 4.91 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles81-81 B. Norris, R (6-13, 4.77 ERA) |
| Oakland A's88-78 B. Zito, L (14-6, 4.21 ERA) | | | Cleveland Indians97-75 C. Anderson, R (12-10, 3.32 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox69-93 A. Sele, R (14-17, 4.89 ERA) | | | Tampa Bay Devil Rays100-68 D. Price, L (14-9, 3.96 ERA) |