| Day 55 |
| 3rd Party Candidates27-27 R. Oswalt, R (2-3, 6.24 ERA) | | | Venice Beach Hulkamaniacs30-24 C. Kershaw, L (3-4, 4.80 ERA) |
| Jersey City Scooters30-24 Y. Darvish, R (4-3, 4.07 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders24-30 J. Shields, R (5-3, 5.32 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns24-30 J. Paxton, L (2-4, 6.97 ERA) | | | Boulder Cavemen21-33 M. Latos, R (5-3, 3.38 ERA) |
| Iowa Corn Pickers31-23 J. Lackey, R (4-4, 6.48 ERA) | | | Florida Crabs26-28 G. Gonzalez, L (2-5, 5.06 ERA) |
| Toronto Tigers28-26 A. Griffin, R (3-4, 5.06 ERA) | | | Saratoga Stallions26-28 R. Porcello, R (3-4, 5.60 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes32-22 S. Bieber, R (4-3, 6.02 ERA) | | | Montana Ducks25-29 F. Liriano, L (4-2, 4.91 ERA) |
| Day Off: Montana Ducks |
| Day 56 |
| 3rd Party Candidates27-27 J. Verlander, R (4-5, 4.68 ERA) | | | Venice Beach Hulkamaniacs30-24 J. Beckett, R (0-4, 5.06 ERA) |
| Jersey City Scooters30-24 R. Hill, L (3-3, 3.75 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders24-30 M. Scherzer, R (7-3, 3.84 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns24-30 C. Kluber, R (2-7, 5.47 ERA) | | | Boulder Cavemen21-33 J. Arrieta, R (3-6, 4.26 ERA) |
| Iowa Corn Pickers31-23 W. Buehler, R (4-5, 6.16 ERA) | | | Florida Crabs26-28 J. deGrom, R (5-3, 3.98 ERA) |
| Toronto Tigers28-26 Z. Greinke, R (3-5, 6.15 ERA) | | | Saratoga Stallions26-28 G. Cole, R (5-3, 3.63 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes32-22 B. Snell, L (5-3, 4.50 ERA) | | | Montana Ducks25-29 J. Flaherty, R (6-4, 2.93 ERA) |
| Day 57 |
| 3rd Party Candidates27-27 A. Nola, R (3-3, 4.92 ERA) | | | Venice Beach Hulkamaniacs30-24 D. Hudson, R (4-3, 4.41 ERA) |
| Jersey City Scooters30-24 S. Strasburg, R (3-4, 5.46 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders24-30 M. Harvey, R (2-6, 6.55 ERA) |
| Arizona Suns24-30 C. Buchholz, R (4-3, 5.05 ERA) | | | Boulder Cavemen21-33 J. Lester, L (3-7, 3.95 ERA) |
| Iowa Corn Pickers31-23 K. Hendricks, R (6-3, 4.94 ERA) | | | Florida Crabs26-28 F. Hernandez, R (5-2, 4.18 ERA) |
| Toronto Tigers28-26 K. Maeda, R (0-3, 5.98 ERA) | | | Saratoga Stallions26-28 C. Hamels, L (5-6, 3.44 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes32-22 G. Richards, R (4-4, 5.01 ERA) | | | Montana Ducks25-29 C. Lee, L (4-5, 6.79 ERA) |