| Day 1 |
| New York Yankees79-83 A. Nola, R (12-17, 3.27 ERA) | | | Oakland Athletics85-85 S. Strasburg, R (10-14, 3.33 ERA) |
| New York Mets102-69 M. Scherzer, R (19-14, 2.37 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals63-99 J. Verlander, R (7-14, 3.40 ERA) |
| Toronto Blue Jays80-82 L. McCullers, R (12-13, 3.92 ERA) | | | Cleveland Indians54-108 J. deGrom, R (2-17, 5.31 ERA) |
| Colorado Rockies67-95 M. Gonzalez, R (12-15, 3.83 ERA) | | | Los Angeles Angels90-77 M. Clevinger, R (10-9, 2.04 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates121-55 L. Giolito, R (20-10, 3.38 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox112-54 R. Ray, L (20-6, 2.71 ERA) |
| Minnesota Twins77-85 L. Castillo, R (14-13, 2.46 ERA) | | | Seattle Mariners103-73 P. Bridwell, R (15-12, 3.30 ERA) |
| Cincinnati Reds92-74 C. Kershaw, L (19-7, 2.77 ERA) | | | Tampa Bay Rays80-82 C. Martinez, R (11-12, 3.61 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Dodgers71-95 C. Sale, L (17-14, 3.55 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs83-79 A. Wood, L (21-6, 2.40 ERA) |
| Washington Nationals84-78 E. Rodriguez, L (12-14, 3.86 ERA) | | | San Diego Padres66-96 C. Kluber, R (7-15, 2.31 ERA) |
| San Francisco Giants69-93 R. Hill, L (9-15, 3.66 ERA) | | | Detroit Tigers73-89 C. Carrasco, R (13-11, 4.90 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| New York Yankees79-83 L. Weaver, R (7-10, 3.63 ERA) | | | Oakland Athletics85-85 G. Gonzalez, L (14-18, 4.38 ERA) |
| New York Mets102-69 L. Severino, R (21-8, 2.35 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals63-99 D. Price, L (5-20, 4.85 ERA) |
| Toronto Blue Jays80-82 G. Cole, R (14-13, 3.35 ERA) | | | Cleveland Indians54-108 M. Tanaka, R (11-7, 3.06 ERA) |
| Colorado Rockies67-95 Z. Greinke, R (10-13, 3.94 ERA) | | | Los Angeles Angels90-77 M. Fulmer, R (13-16, 4.06 ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates121-55 M. Nash, R (20-5, 2.51 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox112-54 D. Lamet, R (19-8, 2.31 ERA) |
| Minnesota Twins77-85 J. Montgomery, L (8-15, 2.94 ERA) | | | Seattle Mariners103-73 B. Woodruff, R (11-7, 4.63 ERA) |
| Cincinnati Reds92-74 D. Bundy, R (16-14, 2.79 ERA) | | | Tampa Bay Rays80-82 J. Gray, R (9-14, 4.90 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Dodgers71-95 N. Syndergaard, R (13-15, 3.02 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs83-79 C. Anderson, R (11-14, 4.07 ERA) |
| Washington Nationals84-78 B. Snell, L (10-17, 5.01 ERA) | | | San Diego Padres66-96 E. Santana, R (9-19, 4.41 ERA) |
| San Francisco Giants69-93 Y. Darvish, R (7-12, 3.76 ERA) | | | Detroit Tigers73-89 J. Arrieta, R (12-15, 4.38 ERA) |