| Day 1 |
| Water Town Mudskippers101-68 J. Arrieta, R (18-8, 2.80 ERA) | | | Base Ball Classics99-69 C. Mathewson, R (19-10, 3.03 ERA) |
| Maine Reapers91-90 P. Alexander, R (23-12, 3.01 ERA) | | | Pasadena Old Ladies71-91 C. Kershaw, L (14-16, 4.27 ERA) |
| Dallas Mustangs79-83 J. Verlander, R (16-12, 3.85 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares65-97 L. Tiant, R (10-17, 5.12 ERA) |
| Jamaica Hensons109-65 J. Richard, R (13-11, 3.92 ERA) | | | Jersey Fence Busters86-83 J. deGrom, R (11-16, 4.02 ERA) |
| Howling Anal FISTULAS74-88 P. Martinez, R (12-13, 4.07 ERA) | | | Iowa Pigs63-99 D. McNally, L (11-18, 4.15 ERA) |
| Carolina Bulldogs77-85 W. Johnson, R (9-12, 3.84 ERA) | | | Canarsie Canibals89-86 S. Koufax, L (16-17, 4.13 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Water Town Mudskippers101-68 N. Ryan, R (13-13, 4.08 ERA) | | | Base Ball Classics99-69 B. Snell, L (21-7, 2.91 ERA) |
| Maine Reapers91-90 J. Cueto, R (10-16, 5.23 ERA) | | | Pasadena Old Ladies71-91 G. Cole, R (10-15, 4.77 ERA) |
| Dallas Mustangs79-83 B. Adams, R (7-8, 4.63 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares65-97 J. Hearn, R (9-15, 5.11 ERA) |
| Jamaica Hensons109-65 V. Blue, L (21-8, 3.37 ERA) | | | Jersey Fence Busters86-83 M. Scherzer, R (18-14, 4.20 ERA) |
| Howling Anal FISTULAS74-88 M. Scott, R (3-14, 5.86 ERA) | | | Iowa Pigs63-99 J. Santana, L (11-12, 4.93 ERA) |
| Carolina Bulldogs77-85 D. White, L (10-20, 4.93 ERA) | | | Canarsie Canibals89-86 B. Gibson, R (13-20, 4.13 ERA) |