| Day 1 |
| Colorado Rockies85-80 D. Pomeranz, L (10-13, 4.84 ERA) | | | Atlanta Braves100-79 B. Beachy, R (19-15, 2.44 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Angels107-62 J. Weaver, R (19-8, 2.49 ERA) | | | New York Yankees85-79 A. Pettitte, L (17-13, 3.89 ERA) |
| Seattle Mariners71-91 F. Hernandez, R (11-18, 2.67 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles91-75 C. Tillman, R (17-12, 3.12 ERA) |
| Oakland Athletics103-71 B. Anderson, L (23-12, 3.79 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies82-80 C. Hamels, L (12-17, 3.55 ERA) |
| Cleveland Indians77-85 Z. McAllister, R (12-16, 4.04 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox82-81 J. Beckett, R (15-17, 4.13 ERA) |
| St. Louis Cardinals95-73 K. Lohse, R (15-16, 3.75 ERA) | | | Washington Nationals91-79 G. Gonzalez, L (23-15, 3.07 ERA) |
| Houston Astros60-102 E. Gonzalez, R (4-18, 4.38 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds85-80 M. Latos, R (17-14, 3.46 ERA) |
| Texas Rangers68-94 C. Lewis, R (8-12, 4.26 ERA) | | | New York Mets83-82 R. Dickey, R (15-15, 2.65 ERA) |
| Detroit Tigers70-92 J. Verlander, R (12-17, 3.71 ERA) | | | Florida Marlins69-93 J. Turner, R (11-20, 6.00 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox87-80 J. Peavy, R (16-12, 3.10 ERA) | | | Toronto Blue Jays101-78 C. Villanueva, R (3-10, 3.75 ERA) |
| San Francisco Giants67-95 M. Cain, R (19-17, 3.80 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers83-79 M. Estrada, R (16-11, 3.68 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Dodgers69-93 C. Kershaw, L (10-27, 3.42 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs77-85 M. Garza, R (10-18, 4.00 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Colorado Rockies85-80 J. Guthrie, R (13-11, 5.38 ERA) | | | Atlanta Braves100-79 T. Hanson, R (2-2, 2.87 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Angels107-62 Z. Greinke, R (17-13, 3.87 ERA) | | | New York Yankees85-79 C. Sabathia, L (20-13, 3.40 ERA) |
| Seattle Mariners71-91 J. Vargas, L (12-21, 4.75 ERA) | | | Baltimore Orioles91-75 J. Hammel, R (19-11, 4.01 ERA) |
| Oakland Athletics103-71 A. Griffin, R (21-9, 2.53 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies82-80 C. Lee, L (14-15, 3.59 ERA) |
| Cleveland Indians77-85 D. Huff, L (11-12, 5.15 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox82-81 C. Buchholz, R (16-18, 4.23 ERA) |
| St. Louis Cardinals95-73 A. Wainwright, R (18-16, 4.61 ERA) | | | Washington Nationals91-79 S. Strasburg, R (17-15, 3.97 ERA) |
| Houston Astros60-102 W. Rodriguez, L (10-19, 4.53 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds85-80 J. Cueto, R (15-20, 4.76 ERA) |
| Texas Rangers68-94 N. Feliz, R (13-18, 2.75 ERA) | | | New York Mets83-82 M. Harvey, R (13-14, 3.54 ERA) |
| Detroit Tigers70-92 D. Smyly, L (6-15, 4.91 ERA) | | | Florida Marlins69-93 M. Buehrle, L (19-17, 4.47 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox87-80 C. Sale, L (16-15, 3.66 ERA) | | | Toronto Blue Jays101-78 A. Laffey, L (3-1, 3.13 ERA) |
| San Francisco Giants67-95 M. Bumgarner, L (9-19, 3.75 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers83-79 Z. Greinke, R (13-16, 4.42 ERA) |
| Los Angeles Dodgers69-93 T. Lilly, L (14-13, 2.74 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs77-85 R. Dempster, R (13-16, 4.73 ERA) |