| Day 1 |
| Team 1 Best Players 168-94 D. Lamet, R (7-9, 0.36 ERA) | | | Team 14 14 Kittens79-83 F. Bradley, R (6-6, 0.67 ERA) |
| Team 16 Underdogs82-80 B. Gibson, R (8-7, 0.36 ERA) | | | Team 10 10Time to win75-87 C. Sale, L (12-5, 0.31 ERA) |
| Team 11 It goes to 1190-79 M. Scott, R (10-3, 0.17 ERA) | | | Team 13 13 serpents91-78 R. Nelson, R (7-5, 0.29 ERA) |
| Team 9 Prime Time Nine71-91 C. Kershaw, L (5-10, 0.38 ERA) | | | Team 12 12 Apostles83-79 D. McNally, L (8-7, 0.40 ERA) |
| Team 7 7 to heaven92-77 C. Young, R (10-10, 0.54 ERA) | | | Team 5 5 for Fighting96-73 D. White, L (11-7, 0.30 ERA) |
| Team 8 8 Great80-82 S. Bieber, R (9-6, 0.34 ERA) | | | Team 4 4th B w U79-83 T. Bauer, R (6-7, 0.19 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Team 1 Best Players 168-94 J. Richard, R (3-10, 0.54 ERA) | | | Team 14 14 Kittens79-83 E. Walsh, R (7-8, 0.25 ERA) |
| Team 16 Underdogs82-80 Z. Greinke, R (9-7, 0.29 ERA) | | | Team 10 10Time to win75-87 S. Paige, R (4-4, 0.11 ERA) |
| Team 11 It goes to 1190-79 D. Bankhead, R (5-8, 0.40 ERA) | | | Team 13 13 serpents91-78 S. Koufax, L (10-7, 0.39 ERA) |
| Team 9 Prime Time Nine71-91 M. Scherzer, R (3-9, 0.42 ERA) | | | Team 12 12 Apostles83-79 W. Johnson, R (5-6, 0.26 ERA) |
| Team 7 7 to heaven92-77 J. Verlander, R (7-8, 0.42 ERA) | | | Team 5 5 for Fighting96-73 D. Brown, L (5-11, 0.36 ERA) |
| Team 8 8 Great80-82 P. Alexander, R (8-7, 0.34 ERA) | | | Team 4 4th B w U79-83 G. Cole, R (4-5, 0.21 ERA) |