| Day 57 |
| New York Yankees35-21 B. Turley, R (6-3, 4.06 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox26-30 F. Sullivan, R (4-7, 4.63 ERA) |
| New York Giants30-26 S. Maglie, R (3-3, 3.92 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Braves25-31 W. Spahn, L (4-7, 4.52 ERA) |
| St Louis Cardinals34-22 V. McDaniel, R (6-3, 3.45 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds32-24 G. Conley, R (7-2, 3.81 ERA) |
| Brooklyn Dodgers20-36 D. Drysdale, R (4-5, 5.96 ERA) | | | Cleveland Indians22-34 H. Score, L (3-9, 5.40 ERA) |
| Day 58 |
| Cincinnati Reds32-24 H. Wehmeier, R (7-3, 5.58 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox26-30 H. Brown, R (4-5, 3.68 ERA) |
| Milwaukee Braves25-31 J. Wilson, R (4-7, 5.46 ERA) | | | Brooklyn Dodgers20-36 B. Loes, R (3-6, 8.02 ERA) |
| New York Giants30-26 H. Haddix, L (6-5, 5.99 ERA) | | | St Louis Cardinals34-22 L. Jackson, R (6-3, 4.31 ERA) |
| Cleveland Indians22-34 C. Erskine, R (1-5, 4.62 ERA) | | | New York Yankees35-21 T. Sturdivant, R (5-4, 5.38 ERA) |
| Day 59 |
| Cincinnati Reds32-24 D. Elston, R (0-5, 6.09 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox26-30 J. Kucks, R (3-4, 4.08 ERA) |
| Milwaukee Braves25-31 L. Burdette, R (3-4, 4.26 ERA) | | | Brooklyn Dodgers20-36 D. Newcombe, R (1-5, 5.34 ERA) |
| New York Giants30-26 D. Gross, L (0-2, 4.76 ERA) | | | St Louis Cardinals34-22 V. Mizell, L (3-3, 6.68 ERA) |
| Cleveland Indians22-34 D. Larsen, R (4-4, 3.36 ERA) | | | New York Yankees35-21 B. Shantz, L (8-4, 4.48 ERA) |