| Day 1 |
| Team 8 Team 885-84 O. Hernandez, R (9-16, 3.18 ERA) | | | Team 1 Team 1108-61 C. Bassitt, R (13-6, 2.51 ERA) |
| Team 12 Team 1276-86 J. Key, L (8-15, 3.59 ERA) | | | Team 2 Team 277-85 K. Maeda, R (8-15, 2.72 ERA) |
| Team 5 Team 571-91 N. Syndergaard, R (13-14, 2.82 ERA) | | | Team 3 Team 3100-69 P. Perez, R (8-14, 2.95 ERA) |
| Team 7 Team 772-90 B. Webb, R (10-12, 2.32 ERA) | | | Team 9 Team 984-85 C. Carpenter, R (11-12, 2.58 ERA) |
| Team 6 Team 676-86 A. Wainwright, R (13-11, 2.07 ERA) | | | Team 10 Team 1090-86 J. Coleman, R (17-7, 2.46 ERA) |
| Team 11 Team 1175-87 M. Bumgarner, L (14-11, 2.15 ERA) | | | Team 4 Team 479-83 J. Rijo, R (9-14, 2.47 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Team 8 Team 885-84 D. Cook, L (6-8, 2.51 ERA) | | | Team 1 Team 1108-61 A. Leiter, L (17-6, 2.06 ERA) |
| Team 12 Team 1276-86 T. Hudson, R (10-17, 2.72 ERA) | | | Team 2 Team 277-85 N. Eovaldi, R (13-15, 2.51 ERA) |
| Team 5 Team 571-91 F. Tanana, L (11-17, 2.84 ERA) | | | Team 3 Team 3100-69 J. Schmidt, R (9-14, 3.39 ERA) |
| Team 7 Team 772-90 J. Reuss, L (13-14, 2.63 ERA) | | | Team 9 Team 984-85 T. Lilly, L (12-11, 2.69 ERA) |
| Team 6 Team 676-86 D. Lowe, R (10-17, 3.57 ERA) | | | Team 10 Team 1090-86 B. Smith, R (1-10, 3.57 ERA) |
| Team 11 Team 1175-87 F. Hernandez, R (10-14, 1.73 ERA) | | | Team 4 Team 479-83 L. Gura, L (12-14, 2.49 ERA) |