| Day 1 |
| Houston Astros 201989-73 J. Verlander, R (12-9, 3.61 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies 201075-87 R. Oswalt, R (10-12, 3.95 ERA) |
| Oakland Athletics 197271-91 V. Blue, L (15-14, 3.67 ERA) | | | New York Mets 200793-75 P. Martinez, R (16-15, 2.58 ERA) |
| Seattle Mariners 199772-90 R. Johnson, L (15-12, 3.59 ERA) | | | Los Angeles Dodgers 202299-63 C. Kershaw, L (12-14, 3.60 ERA) |
| New York Yankees 202279-87 G. Cole, R (10-11, 4.89 ERA) | | | Atlanta Braves 199798-70 G. Maddux, R (17-12, 3.89 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox 200485-81 P. Martinez, R (15-12, 3.85 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs 201683-79 J. Arrieta, R (15-11, 3.24 ERA) |
| Detroit Tigers 201276-86 J. Verlander, R (9-16, 3.83 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals 196871-91 B. Gibson, R (13-15, 3.84 ERA) |
| Baltimore Orioles 196974-88 D. McNally, L (11-18, 3.97 ERA) | | | Arizona DBacks 200180-82 R. Johnson, L (15-10, 4.46 ERA) |
| Cleveland Guardians 199777-85 O. Hershiser, R (11-14, 5.01 ERA) | | | San Francisco Giants 200184-78 J. Schmidt, R (11-13, 5.26 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Houston Astros 201989-73 G. Cole, R (14-8, 3.19 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies 201075-87 C. Hamels, L (13-13, 4.60 ERA) |
| Oakland Athletics 197271-91 C. Hunter, R (10-14, 4.57 ERA) | | | New York Mets 200793-75 O. Perez, L (13-6, 3.87 ERA) |
| Seattle Mariners 199772-90 D. Lowe, R (6-14, 5.43 ERA) | | | Los Angeles Dodgers 202299-63 T. Gonsolin, R (12-7, 2.85 ERA) |
| New York Yankees 202279-87 N. Cortes Jr., L (10-18, 4.74 ERA) | | | Atlanta Braves 199798-70 K. Millwood, R (17-13, 4.29 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox 200485-81 C. Schilling, R (12-16, 5.50 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs 201683-79 K. Hendricks, R (13-13, 4.17 ERA) |
| Detroit Tigers 201276-86 M. Scherzer, R (16-6, 3.73 ERA) | | | St. Louis Cardinals 196871-91 S. Carlton, L (14-15, 3.60 ERA) |
| Baltimore Orioles 196974-88 J. Palmer, R (14-15, 3.96 ERA) | | | Arizona DBacks 200180-82 C. Schilling, R (11-15, 4.85 ERA) |
| Cleveland Guardians 199777-85 J. Smiley, L (10-13, 6.93 ERA) | | | San Francisco Giants 200184-78 L. Hernandez, R (9-14, 5.44 ERA) |