| Day 1 |
| Tommy Tommy BB10-6 J. Richard, R (2-0, 3.15 ERA) | | | Tommy Tommy AA7-9 J. Santana, L (0-2, 4.50 ERA) |
| Andy Andy BB9-8 D. Gooden, R (1-1, 4.05 ERA) | | | Graeme Graeme AA9-8 R. Nelson, R (0-2, 6.75 ERA) |
| Dave Dave BB10-6 R. Clemens, R (1-1, 6.75 ERA) | | | Andy Andy AA4-12 N. Ryan, R (1-1, 3.77 ERA) |
| Murph Murph BB7-9 C. Hunter, R (0-2, 9.50 ERA) | | | Murph Murph AA9-7 B. Snell, L (1-1, 10.13 ERA) |
| Graeme Graeme BB10-6 C. Bender, R (0-2, 13.86 ERA) | | | Dave Dave AA6-10 T. Hughes, R (1-1, 3.27 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| Tommy Tommy BB10-6 V. Blue, L (2-1, 2.88 ERA) | | | Tommy Tommy AA7-9 R. Johnson, L (0-1, 9.82 ERA) |
| Andy Andy BB9-8 S. Koufax, L (2-1, 6.44 ERA) | | | Graeme Graeme AA9-8 A. Joss, R (2-0, 3.04 ERA) |
| Dave Dave BB10-6 M. Brown, R (2-0, 4.79 ERA) | | | Andy Andy AA4-12 C. Young, R (0-2, 4.73 ERA) |
| Murph Murph BB7-9 E. Cicotte, R (2-1, 4.50 ERA) | | | Murph Murph AA9-7 J. Cueto, R (1-1, 2.78 ERA) |
| Graeme Graeme BB10-6 C. Bender, R (0-2, 13.86 ERA) | | | Dave Dave AA6-10 F. Hernandez, R (2-1, 2.33 ERA) |
| Day 3 |
| Tommy Tommy BB10-6 D. McNally, L (1-2, 6.91 ERA) | | | Tommy Tommy AA7-9 J. deGrom, R (2-1, 3.08 ERA) |
| Andy Andy BB9-8 P. Alexander, R (2-1, 3.82 ERA) | | | Graeme Graeme AA9-8 J. Schmidt, R (2-2, 4.37 ERA) |
| Dave Dave BB10-6 P. Martinez, R (2-1, 4.02 ERA) | | | Andy Andy AA4-12 L. Tiant, R (1-1, 4.85 ERA) |
| Murph Murph BB7-9 J. Chesbro, R (2-0, 4.24 ERA) | | | Murph Murph AA9-7 R. Caldwell, R (1-1, 5.79 ERA) |
| Graeme Graeme BB10-6 C. Bender, R (0-2, 13.86 ERA) | | | Dave Dave AA6-10 W. Johnson, R (1-2, 3.38 ERA) |