| Day 85 |
| Genes Greens Hooligans46-38 B. Adams, R (6-6, 5.19 ERA) | | | Chapmanville Romans45-39 S. Koufax, L (7-5, 3.82 ERA) |
| Franklin Redlegs31-53 W. White, R (5-9, 5.25 ERA) | | | Yard Goats56-28 J. Jones, R (8-5, 4.49 ERA) |
| Swamp Donkeys60-24 F. Valenzuela, L (6-4, 5.60 ERA) | | | Teays Valley Rage41-43 S. Strasburg, R (4-3, 4.02 ERA) |
| Grim Reapers32-52 D. McLain, R (8-8, 5.10 ERA) | | | Saint Albans Kingpins51-33 T. Skubal, L (4-10, 5.87 ERA) |
| Holy Ghost39-45 A. Pond, R (6-7, 4.54 ERA) | | | Dead Legends38-46 P. Smith, L (3-7, 5.36 ERA) |
| Holden Trojans47-37 L. Tiant, R (5-7, 6.35 ERA) | | | Cross Lanes Dodgers36-48 T. Glasnow, R (3-4, 4.84 ERA) |
| Cameron Dragons39-45 T. McKenzie, R (2-6, 4.46 ERA) | | | East Bank Pioneers52-32 T. Bauer, R (6-8, 6.07 ERA) |
| Erie Spectres34-50 T. Bond, R (7-9, 3.96 ERA) | | | Hell Cats25-59 D. Brown, L (4-10, 6.11 ERA) |
| Day 86 |
| Genes Greens Hooligans46-38 B. Milacki, R (6-6, 4.37 ERA) | | | Chapmanville Romans45-39 G. McQuillan, R (5-5, 4.33 ERA) |
| Franklin Redlegs31-53 F. Tanana, L (7-6, 4.03 ERA) | | | Yard Goats56-28 L. Cadore, R (15-1, 2.68 ERA) |
| Swamp Donkeys60-24 K. Spooner, L (9-5, 3.65 ERA) | | | Teays Valley Rage41-43 K. Maeda, R (3-8, 6.10 ERA) |
| Grim Reapers32-52 D. Leonard, L (7-7, 5.30 ERA) | | | Saint Albans Kingpins51-33 J. Cotton, R (10-3, 5.04 ERA) |
| Holy Ghost39-45 H. Wilson, R (7-8, 4.61 ERA) | | | Dead Legends38-46 C. Lundgren, R (8-5, 4.59 ERA) |
| Holden Trojans47-37 D. White, L (11-5, 5.69 ERA) | | | Cross Lanes Dodgers36-48 S. Bieber, R (5-11, 4.98 ERA) |
| Cameron Dragons39-45 M. Scherzer, R (5-12, 6.11 ERA) | | | East Bank Pioneers52-32 S. Carlton, L (5-6, 6.34 ERA) |
| Erie Spectres34-50 N. Ryan, R (6-8, 4.63 ERA) | | | Hell Cats25-59 H. Smith, R (4-9, 4.53 ERA) |
| Day 87 |
| Genes Greens Hooligans46-38 C. Kluber, R (6-7, 5.24 ERA) | | | Chapmanville Romans45-39 F. Schupp, L (6-2, 3.12 ERA) |
| Franklin Redlegs31-53 B. Walters, R (6-7, 4.67 ERA) | | | Yard Goats56-28 T. Ramsey, L (6-6, 5.62 ERA) |
| Swamp Donkeys60-24 A. Joss, R (8-3, 5.15 ERA) | | | Teays Valley Rage41-43 T. Gonsolin, R (5-2, 5.26 ERA) |
| Grim Reapers32-52 S. Chandler, R (2-9, 6.78 ERA) | | | Saint Albans Kingpins51-33 G. Hecker, R (7-4, 4.74 ERA) |
| Holy Ghost39-45 G. Walker, R (6-4, 4.01 ERA) | | | Dead Legends38-46 H. McCormick, R (5-6, 4.28 ERA) |
| Holden Trojans47-37 R. Hill, L (7-4, 5.27 ERA) | | | Cross Lanes Dodgers36-48 C. Young, R (6-5, 5.31 ERA) |
| Cameron Dragons39-45 M. Fiers, R (4-6, 6.06 ERA) | | | East Bank Pioneers52-32 B. Gibson, R (7-4, 5.38 ERA) |
| Erie Spectres34-50 J. McGinnity, R (3-8, 4.67 ERA) | | | Hell Cats25-59 C. Mathewson, R (0-12, 5.80 ERA) |