| Day 1 |
| Detroit Motors0-0 J. Verlander, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Boston Minutemen0-0 P. Martinez, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Cincinnati Red Stockings0-0 J. Cueto, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Philadelphia Bells0-0 P. Alexander, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| San Francisco Seals0-0 J. Marichal, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | St. Louis Arches0-0 B. Gibson, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Oakland Elephants0-0 V. Blue, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Chicago Wind0-0 J. Arrieta, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Cleveland Rockers0-0 L. Tiant, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | New York Apples0-0 J. deGrom, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Pittsburgh Rivers0-0 B. Adams, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Beltway Bandits0-0 D. McNally, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Los Angeles Palms0-0 C. Kershaw, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Atlanta Fire0-0 G. Maddux, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Las Vegas Gamblers0-0 R. Clemens, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Milwaukee Hardhats0-0 C. Burnes, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| St. Louis Arches0-0 J. Tudor, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Las Vegas Gamblers0-0 D. Gooden, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Philadelphia Bells0-0 C. Bender, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | San Francisco Seals0-0 J. Schmidt, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Cleveland Rockers0-0 C. Kluber, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Cincinnati Red Stockings0-0 M. Soto, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Atlanta Fire0-0 K. Millwood, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Oakland Elephants0-0 C. Hunter, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Milwaukee Hardhats0-0 T. Higuera, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Chicago Wind0-0 E. Walsh, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Boston Minutemen0-0 C. Sale, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Los Angeles Palms0-0 S. Koufax, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Beltway Bandits0-0 M. Scherzer, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Detroit Motors0-0 D. McLain, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| New York Apples0-0 G. Cole, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Rivers0-0 J. Chesbro, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Day 3 |
| Oakland Elephants0-0 R. Harden, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Boston Minutemen0-0 D. Leonard, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Las Vegas Gamblers0-0 K. Brown, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Philadelphia Bells0-0 R. Waddell, L (0-0, - ERA) |
| Chicago Wind0-0 M. Brown, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | St. Louis Arches0-0 A. Wainwright, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| San Francisco Seals0-0 G. Perry, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Cleveland Rockers0-0 A. Joss, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Cincinnati Red Stockings0-0 B. Walters, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | New York Apples0-0 C. Mathewson, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Los Angeles Palms0-0 Z. Greinke, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Beltway Bandits0-0 W. Johnson, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Milwaukee Hardhats0-0 B. Sheets, R (0-0, - ERA) | | | Atlanta Fire0-0 J. Smoltz, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Detroit Motors0-0 F. Tanana, L (0-0, - ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Rivers0-0 J. Candelaria, L (0-0, - ERA) |