| Day 37 |
| New York SHEEP22-14 D. Wells, L (4-0, 4.34 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers17-19 F. Peralta, R (2-3, 3.68 ERA) |
| DODGERS LEGENDS22-14 Y. Yamamoto, R (3-1, 3.83 ERA) | | | Houston Astros19-17 R. Johnson, L (1-2, 7.71 ERA) |
| Toronto FillJays12-24 J. Happ, L (1-3, 5.67 ERA) | | | Oakland Athletics19-17 C. Hunter, R (5-2, 2.24 ERA) |
| Missouri Tornados16-20 D. Cox, R (1-5, 4.50 ERA) | | | Baltimore FillBirds15-21 S. Davis, R (3-1, 4.01 ERA) |
| New York Metropolitans27-9 M. Scherzer, R (4-2, 2.66 ERA) | | | Atlanta FillBraves16-20 G. Maddux, R (5-2, 2.75 ERA) |
| Cincy FillReds12-24 J. Rijo, R (3-3, 5.44 ERA) | | | Oakland FillAs19-17 B. Zito, L (4-1, 2.06 ERA) |
| Day 38 |
| New York SHEEP22-14 M. Fried, L (3-4, 5.93 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers17-19 B. Woodruff, R (2-3, 4.22 ERA) |
| DODGERS LEGENDS22-14 D. May, R (0-1, 4.24 ERA) | | | Houston Astros19-17 B. Peacock, R (0-2, 5.84 ERA) |
| Toronto FillJays12-24 M. Estrada, R (2-3, 3.65 ERA) | | | Oakland Athletics19-17 V. Blue, L (1-3, 4.97 ERA) |
| Missouri Tornados16-20 J. Tudor, L (3-2, 4.31 ERA) | | | Baltimore FillBirds15-21 W. Chen, L (0-3, 5.67 ERA) |
| New York Metropolitans27-9 D. Gooden, R (6-1, 1.71 ERA) | | | Atlanta FillBraves16-20 C. Morton, R (1-3, 5.63 ERA) |
| Cincy FillReds12-24 S. Gray, R (1-6, 5.50 ERA) | | | Oakland FillAs19-17 D. Stewart, R (3-2, 4.66 ERA) |
| Day 39 |
| New York SHEEP22-14 C. Sabathia, L (3-3, 3.91 ERA) | | | Milwaukee Brewers17-19 T. Higuera, L (4-2, 4.53 ERA) |
| DODGERS LEGENDS22-14 T. Bauer, R (2-2, 3.13 ERA) | | | Houston Astros19-17 F. Valdez, L (4-1, 2.36 ERA) |
| Toronto FillJays12-24 D. Stieb, R (1-2, 3.91 ERA) | | | Oakland Athletics19-17 K. Holtzman, L (3-4, 5.89 ERA) |
| Missouri Tornados16-20 T. Stottlemyre, R (2-3, 3.64 ERA) | | | Baltimore FillBirds15-21 U. Jimenez, R (2-3, 6.75 ERA) |
| New York Metropolitans27-9 S. Fernandez, L (3-1, 2.72 ERA) | | | Atlanta FillBraves16-20 J. Smoltz, R (0-5, 7.20 ERA) |
| Cincy FillReds12-24 T. Mahle, R (1-4, 5.82 ERA) | | | Oakland FillAs19-17 M. Mulder, L (3-3, 4.14 ERA) |