| Day 51 |
| Oostburg Slammers24-26 M. Scott, R (4-5, 4.08 ERA) | | | Las Vegas Gladiators21-29 M. Soto, R (5-4, 4.86 ERA) |
| Quebec Diamants31-19 R. Clemens, R (7-2, 4.26 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders24-26 T. Higuera, L (4-6, 2.57 ERA) |
| 1985 NL All Stars19-31 J. Andujar, R (2-7, 3.71 ERA) | | | Dallas Mustangs19-31 P. Perez, R (1-8, 4.38 ERA) |
| Kansas City Monarchs26-24 N. Ryan, R (4-2, 2.81 ERA) | | | Kentucky Horses28-22 J. Candelaria, L (3-4, 3.97 ERA) |
| Denver Eagles29-21 J. Richard, R (7-2, 1.66 ERA) | | | Paper City Hood Rats34-16 D. Gooden, R (6-2, 3.58 ERA) |
| Phoenix Bandits22-28 R. Reuschel, R (2-6, 6.23 ERA) | | | Miami Serpents23-27 R. Guidry, L (6-3, 2.40 ERA) |
| Day 52 |
| Las Vegas Gladiators21-29 C. Cary, L (1-6, 5.55 ERA) | | | Quebec Diamants31-19 F. Valenzuela, L (5-1, 2.78 ERA) |
| Dallas Mustangs19-31 J. Tudor, L (4-1, 2.63 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders24-26 J. DeLeon, R (4-5, 3.17 ERA) |
| Paper City Hood Rats34-16 D. Righetti, L (5-2, 3.84 ERA) | | | Oostburg Slammers24-26 B. Saberhagen, R (3-4, 3.35 ERA) |
| Phoenix Bandits22-28 S. Carlton, L (4-3, 3.65 ERA) | | | Kansas City Monarchs26-24 B. Ojeda, L (4-3, 3.74 ERA) |
| Miami Serpents23-27 R. May, L (2-4, 6.95 ERA) | | | Denver Eagles29-21 D. Sutton, R (4-2, 2.97 ERA) |
| Kentucky Horses28-22 J. Rijo, R (1-3, 3.57 ERA) | | | 1985 NL All Stars19-31 R. Darling, R (2-3, 5.76 ERA) |
| Day 53 |
| Las Vegas Gladiators21-29 S. Sanderson, R (0-7, 7.48 ERA) | | | Quebec Diamants31-19 O. Hershiser, R (4-3, 6.11 ERA) |
| Dallas Mustangs19-31 S. Garrelts, R (6-2, 3.78 ERA) | | | Charlotte Spiders24-26 J. Denny, R (5-3, 3.08 ERA) |
| Paper City Hood Rats34-16 T. Seaver, R (7-2, 2.42 ERA) | | | Oostburg Slammers24-26 L. Gura, L (4-3, 3.14 ERA) |
| Phoenix Bandits22-28 S. McCatty, R (3-6, 8.06 ERA) | | | Kansas City Monarchs26-24 F. Youmans, R (4-2, 3.32 ERA) |
| Miami Serpents23-27 A. Hammaker, L (4-4, 4.15 ERA) | | | Denver Eagles29-21 M. Norris, R (3-5, 3.60 ERA) |
| Kentucky Horses28-22 M. Krukow, R (4-5, 5.05 ERA) | | | 1985 NL All Stars19-31 R. Sutcliffe, R (4-4, 5.83 ERA) |