| Day 16 |
| Chicago Reapers5-10 C. Kershaw, L (2-1, 3.86 ERA) | | | 12th Man Fixer Uppers 410-5 S. McDowell, L (1-0, 4.76 ERA) |
| Visalia Oaks8-7 W. Johnson, R (1-2, 4.66 ERA) | | | Northwest Lumberjacks5-10 S. Koufax, L (3-0, 1.09 ERA) |
| Bail Out9-6 J. Verlander, R (2-1, 3.86 ERA) | | | Raleigh Screwballs8-7 J. Arrieta, R (0-3, 11.57 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes4-11 J. deGrom, R (2-1, 2.79 ERA) | | | Las Vegas Gladiators11-4 C. Sale, L (0-2, 3.93 ERA) |
| Arkansas Dirt Devils10-5 R. Hill, L (1-1, 7.56 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares6-9 L. Tiant, R (0-2, 5.68 ERA) |
| Sacramento Lions7-8 E. Walsh, R (3-0, 1.38 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder7-8 D. McNally, L (1-2, 5.16 ERA) |
| Day 17 |
| Chicago Reapers5-10 J. Santana, L (2-0, 2.75 ERA) | | | 12th Man Fixer Uppers 410-5 G. Cole, R (1-1, 6.17 ERA) |
| Visalia Oaks8-7 M. Scott, R (2-1, 4.87 ERA) | | | Northwest Lumberjacks5-10 D. Leonard, L (1-2, 4.32 ERA) |
| Bail Out9-6 R. Ford, R (1-1, 4.00 ERA) | | | Raleigh Screwballs8-7 B. Gibson, R (1-1, 3.38 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes4-11 C. Kluber, R (0-3, 6.98 ERA) | | | Las Vegas Gladiators11-4 R. Nelson, R (1-1, 7.36 ERA) |
| Arkansas Dirt Devils10-5 G. Maddux, R (2-1, 4.57 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares6-9 D. Sutton, R (1-0, 6.16 ERA) |
| Sacramento Lions7-8 J. Richard, R (1-2, 3.72 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder7-8 E. Cicotte, R (1-1, 4.79 ERA) |
| Day 18 |
| Chicago Reapers5-10 J. Hearn, R (0-3, 3.66 ERA) | | | 12th Man Fixer Uppers 410-5 R. Johnson, L (2-1, 2.96 ERA) |
| Visalia Oaks8-7 B. Snell, L (2-0, 1.42 ERA) | | | Northwest Lumberjacks5-10 C. Mathewson, R (0-3, 7.02 ERA) |
| Bail Out9-6 H. Score, L (0-1, 13.50 ERA) | | | Raleigh Screwballs8-7 Z. Greinke, R (2-0, 1.23 ERA) |
| Nevada Snakes4-11 J. Horlen, R (0-3, 13.85 ERA) | | | Las Vegas Gladiators11-4 A. Joss, R (3-0, 0.35 ERA) |
| Arkansas Dirt Devils10-5 V. Blue, L (2-1, 3.04 ERA) | | | Utah Nightmares6-9 F. Hernandez, R (1-2, 6.48 ERA) |
| Sacramento Lions7-8 C. Hunter, R (0-2, 6.50 ERA) | | | Pittsburgh Plunder7-8 B. Adams, R (1-1, 2.93 ERA) |