| Day 1 |
| New York Giants81-85 T. Keefe, R (13-20, 4.11 ERA) | | | New York Yankees86-84 R. Ford, R (17-15, 3.18 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox82-85 E. Walsh, R (16-18, 2.99 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox98-75 W. Johnson, R (20-16, 3.36 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox82-85 H. Suter, L (12-20, 4.09 ERA) | | | New York Giants81-85 J. Tesreau, R (19-16, 4.39 ERA) |
| Boston Red Sox98-75 D. Leonard, L (19-8, 2.46 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Phillies76-91 G. McQuillan, R (12-16, 3.71 ERA) |
| Philadelphia Phillies76-91 P. Alexander, R (19-20, 3.46 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Athletics111-67 H. Krause, L (25-17, 3.01 ERA) |
| Philadelphia Athletics111-67 J. Coombs, R (24-14, 3.72 ERA) | | | Cincinnati Reds64-98 F. Harter, R (11-12, 2.75 ERA) |
| New York Yankees86-84 C. Hoff, L (14-13, 2.93 ERA) | | | Boston Braves70-92 C. Radbourn, R (13-23, 4.54 ERA) |
| Detroit Wolverines82-86 B. Lelivelt, R (22-11, 2.48 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs97-84 R. Kroh, L (21-17, 3.31 ERA) |
| Detroit Wolverines82-86 F. Goldsmith, R (14-22, 4.23 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs97-84 R. Hagerman, R (18-9, 3.21 ERA) |
| Day 2 |
| New York Giants81-85 L. Drucke, R (21-13, 3.80 ERA) | | | New York Yankees86-84 J. Lynch, R (13-18, 4.90 ERA) |
| Chicago White Sox82-85 L. Corcoran, R (20-15, 2.23 ERA) | | | Boston Red Sox98-75 J. Wood, R (18-14, 3.38 ERA) |
| Philadelphia Phillies76-91 B. Sanders, R (9-25, 5.09 ERA) | | | Philadelphia Athletics111-67 B. Caruthers, R (0-0, - ERA) |
| Detroit Wolverines82-86 H. Dauss, R (9-8, 3.50 ERA) | | | Chicago Cubs97-84 K. Cole, R (0-0, - ERA) |