Existing User? Login here!


Back to Boards

Wow...crazy trade offered


Wow...crazy trade offered

https://www.pennantchase.com/lgHome.. All Time Greats league, near Mid break, I'm tied for 1st. I have OFs Cobb, T. Williams, M. Ramirez, W. Mays. Cobb Rk99, is having ok season, not great, and I'm barley top 6 offense. I know pitching is king is this league, and I was offered a trade by a team practically out of it, but they have Sherzer who is ridiculous 11-3. Not sure their rational, but the offer is Sherzer and OF L. Gonzalez, for Cobb and Sutton (8-6)! What to do

Re: Wow...crazy trade offered

Basically Scherzer (a top SP) for Cobb (a top hitter). What was crazy? If you’re loaded at OF might make sense to take Scherzer. But I bet some All Time Great professionals can better answer.

Re: Wow...crazy trade offered

You can never have enough pitching. Dont get to tied down to the rank, look at defense as well. Also, you can reject the trade and make a counter offer.

Re: Wow...crazy trade offered

Not the best at ATG but I'd take it. You are loaded at OF and Max Scherzer is one of the better SP out there (though by all means far from the best)... Ultimately it's your call, but I feel that's not a bad deal...

Re: Re: Wow...crazy trade offered

lol, I meant is was crazy cuz I don't think you see many No Drop Players swapping teams.

Re: Wow...crazy trade offered

You do have a point there, mostly because no-drops can only be swapped for other no-drops. and it always has to be an even trade: one or more no-drops for an identical amount of no-drops

Do bear in mind though, trading Cobb while he has a contract means that that owner will get him for at least another season depending on how long the contract was...

Edit: Oops. I didn't realize Cobb's contract was up after that season. My mistake lol